This was a fantastic book!

I thoroughly enjoyed this novel. The characters were very engaging, and the mysterious plot kept me constantly listening until the very end. I was sad to hear the last words - I wanted more! It was so wonderfully woven together with a satisfied ending, that I had to get on here at rate it right away. I highly recommend this -- you won't be disappointed! Who doesn't love a mystery about libraries and astronomy and old books and gypsies?

12 people found this helpful

Great Story..Great Narration

I received this book from Librarything Early Review Program and with so much going on in my life I’ve gotten behind on my ER’s so I picked this one up on audio and am very glad I did as Jilly Bond’s narration was really good, so this will be a review of the book and the narration.

Recently widowed antique appraiser Jude is trying to get on with her life but she can’t stop thinking of her husband so she decides to take a working vacation to look at some old astronomy texts and equipment and this is when the coincidences start. The estate where these things are is where Jude’s Great Grandfather was groundskeeper and where her Grandmother grew up, but she doesn’t like to talk too much about that time of her life except that there was a gypsy girl. It is also close to her sister and niece who seem to be having the same dreams Jude had as a child. Is that possible? And what is her grandmother hiding? Also why does this place look like the dreams Jude had as a child?

I thought the author did a great job at weaving the past and present storylines together and the mystery of the dreams and what happened to Esther in the 1700’s. I enjoyed the mystery of Esther, this 18th century foundling adopted by rich amateur astronomer they are a happy father and daughter and he seems to love sharing his love of the stars with her, but her story isn’t always a happy one and when Jude finds her journals she starts to unlock the mystery of Esther’s life. This has a magical realism feel to it with the astrology and the dreams. It also has a touch of romance but it doesn’t over power the book. I enjoyed this new to me author’s writing style and will definitely read more by her.

If you are a fan of Kate Morton or Susanna Kearsley I think you will like this book it has the same kind of feel to it with the present story mixed in with the past.

Narrator Jilly Bond brought this story to life for me, her voices were well done and her male & female characters weren’t overdone. I was impressed with her work and will seek out other books narrated by her.

4 Stars

11 people found this helpful

Past and present intertwine

This book began slow for me it took me over an hour to get into it. However, I did eventually become invested in the characters. The familial relationships were intriguing- especially between the sisters.
The pieces of the mysteries (plural) fit a little too neatly and intertwined together too much to be completely plausible. And a lot of the mystery is revealed through dream sequences which I thought was an interesting way to intertwine the past (1700's) with the present.
There is bonus information such as: astronomy, travelers/gypsies and a tour through the English countryside.
The story explores themes of loss, regret, love, and complex family relationships.
I would probably give this book a little less them 4 stars. But if like me you like historical fiction such as Kate Morton books, you will enjoy this story.
I would read another book by this author. The narrator was pretty good.

4 people found this helpful

history, mystery and science, oh my

This is a fun, engaging read. Revelations keep appearing until nearly the final page. If you tend to be archival in your own research and enjoy the kinds of discoveries that come from exploring old houses, books and public records you will enjoy this book. The author engages us in the science of astronomy through historical revelations and the romance of stargazing. A new favorite for me.

8 people found this helpful

Marvelous read !!

Any additional comments?

I am such a fan of the books of Kate Morton, but I despaired of ever finding a book that would enthrall me as hers do. How lucky I feel to have found this one !! The main character's story is so absorbing, leading the reader into the maze with an inevitability that is magical... And the narrator is absolutely wonderful. Highly recommended, and now I want MORE books by this author.

3 people found this helpful

Prepare to be Annoyed

This book wasn’t for you, but who do you think might enjoy it more?

The "supernatural" elements in the book may draw readers who like to dabble in fantasy and sci-fi very now and then but wouldn't call themselves "fans" of the genre.

Would you ever listen to anything by Rachel Hore again?

I think I might give the author another chance, but not after just "reading" several books in the genre. It's too predictable and then at times so drawn out I found myself checking to see how many minutes were left until "the end" credits.

I especially didn't like the supernatural elements in the storyline. I was expecting something more realistic and, well, explainable in terms of real world experiences.

Would you be willing to try another one of Jilly Bond’s performances?

NO - the voice drove me crazy. I thought maybe there had been a download glitch the way the cadence fell and rose then sped up unnaturally. The emotional inflections also seemed overly emphasized and at times entirely unwarranted.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

I liked the gypsy angle and wish there had been more of it

2 people found this helpful

Torn-loved the plot, but...

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

For the most part. The plot was extremely interesting and well done. Would have loved to give it another star. However, the relationships were all right out of a juvenile romance novel.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Esther. Was the most interesting.

What didn’t you like about Jilly Bond’s performance?

Too uneven. She kept changing styles for the characters. The children's voices were cloying. I did love her grandmother voice, though.

2 people found this helpful

Great mystery...like an adult fairy tale

I love how this story slowly unfolded. And it had more twists and turns that I adored. But the narrator was not my favorite by far. Even adjusting for the English accent I did not care for her voices for any of the characters except for the main one. When she did the children, it was really not attractive. But the story more than made up for it.

3 people found this helpful

The book that never got there

In honesty, I didn't finish listening. Definitely my preferences pushed me to move on. Too much little old lady to little young lady and I've never been a big fan of heavy British accented narration. But I try from time to time. This time simply didn't catch me.

2 people found this helpful

A story of hidden history, architecture

I enjoyed the story and really wanted more of these characters. I was walking beside the characters as they left messages and clues for the future.