Engaging story beautifully read

I loved this book- Not all authors are good readers, but Ruth Ozeki does a marvelous job with this one. Interesting cultural and philosophical and generational contrasts. The story was very engaging in that I found myself glued to it wanting to know what would happen. I cared about the characters and how they fared. I appreciate the moments of magical realism, the mysteries that are left mysteries, the author's allowing the girl narrator to be both wise and shallow, as young people often are. The characters are more real for their flaws. The language is beautiful, the story well-constructed.

One word of caution - there is a lot of discussion of, and exploration of suicide in this book. At times it is uncomfortable - and I imagine that for someone with close experience or unprocessed hurt around this issue, it may be intolerably so. But it is integral to the book and the story, and involves Japanese history and perspectives on this issue. The tension of Japanese and American ways of understanding suicide is part of the story. That the author elicits this in (American) readers is also part of it. So choose accordingly.

For me it was well worth the read.

79 people found this helpful

Where Darkness Meets Light

Audiobook narration by the author was especially beneficial. There are so many languages and characters in this book, that I'm not sure I would have been able to create the same image in my own head as I read the paper copy. I had the paper copy beside me the whole time, to jot down notes and bookmark notable quotes and sections. The paper copy has a lot of footnotes and annotations, and being able to see Japanese characters in print added to the enjoyment of the overall story.

I am so glad I felt a time crunch to read this book, otherwise I may have missed out on the audio version in Ruth's own voice & story telling capabilities.

The story got dark for a while and the graphic depiction of many disturbing scenes stuck with me, but when light returned near the end, the light was bright enough to carry me through.

18 people found this helpful

Childish then sexual then quantam physics

This is not about a girl writing the story of her grandmother's life, as the description says. It is a childish diary, and I thought at first might be good for youth- not mentioned in the review. The main character is then led into prostitution and there is some sexual content that I would not recommend for youth. Finally, in the last few pages, one ends up reading about quantum physics, and lightly addresses an undeveloped relationship. I can't recommend it for anyone. The author should write about the grandmother's life and her wisdom as promised.

16 people found this helpful

Remarkable

I went into this book with no preconceptions of it's contents. What I found was a series of beautiful echos - within the lives of the characters, as well as my own mind. The story contains frank discussions of self, was, suicide, and cultural belonging framed by a mysterious diary detailing the troubled life of a 15 year old Japanese girl, and the Canadian woman who reads it. It is a mystery, a journey, a spiritual endeavor, and a philosophical sampler. I very much enjoyed this book, and one even before the resolution came that I needed to buy this book in print as well, to ensure I read it again at a later point in my life. The audiobook format is wonderful though, as the author gives literal voice to the characters, providing accents and emphasis on a way that wouldn't come across as well simply printed.
This was a delight, please give it a try.

13 people found this helpful

Extraordinary Effort

Ordinarily I do not like to hear an author read his/her own books. Almost always they come across as emotionless and wooden, and one cannot help but wonder why in the world wouldn't a professional WRITER delegate the narration to a professional READER? This is not the case with this book. Ruth Ozeki's reading skills rival that of any I have ever heard. She definitely improves on her written words with her spoken words. Actually I cannot imagine anyone doing a better job than she.
It would seem that the Ruth in this book is the alter-ego of the author, who is drawn to some flotsam on the beach where she finds, among other artifacts, a diary protected within some plastic freezer bags. It soon becomes apparent the diary came from Japan, and although unlikely, possibly from the devastating tsunami of 2011. The diary was written by a Japanese teenager, Nao (not a coincidence that the pronunciation is "Now") who was contemplating suicide. Nao speaks to her reader across an ocean of water and time, and Ruth is drawn deeper into Nao's life. A captivating connection is made between the two through the girl's story, in spite of the chasm of time and space.
This is truly an elegant, lovely, poignant and thought-provoking novel and Ruth Ozeki has proven she is a brilliant author AND narrator. Highly recommended.

43 people found this helpful

So unusual

I loved this book. I am not sure I can articulate everything about why,but I will try -- it is a wonderful story and pulls in many,many layers of human angst and resolution at just the right time while keeping the story line sane and magical at the same time. Ruth Ozeki reads it beautifully (not always the case with authors) and the characters are well drawn with a clear and significant plunge into new worlds. It was this - the fact that the book took me to another world. that captivated me

The fall season is a good time to be transported to another place while a transition is happening before our eyes. Don't miss this one.

15 people found this helpful

Somewhat Bothersome

I almost always enjoy reading anything from a Japanese author because I find their use on symbolism and storytelling somewhere far off from the Twilight Zone. "A Tale for the Time Being" left me a very dark place where I used to be during my adolescence age. I suffered through depression and managed to dug myself from that dark hole. But, reading about suicide, child torture, death and some kind of weird fantasy was somewhat bothersome.

I happened to agree with other reviewers that Ruth Ozeki is an awesome writer and I will follow her work in the future. Maybe "A Tale for the Time Being" wasn't for me? Maybe I should had started with something lighter from this author?

As I read more into this novel, I found myself going into that dark place again. This book is extremely dark and there is no light. The stories in this book is very realistic, where I imagined myself doing the same thing. A book club would been helpful to have a healthy conversation on what we just finished.

6 people found this helpful

Very inventive

Would you listen to A Tale for the Time Being again? Why?

The two stories that comprise this books are wonderfully intertwined. Save for a few times where it did not make sense to me, the story is well constructed and has a nice flow to it. Unusual in places, but easy to connect to the feelings of the main characters. It alternately describes life in Canada, Silicon Valley and Japan, it touches themes of suicide, purpose and spiritualism. And it comes to a satisfying conclusion.

5 people found this helpful

New title: if you have time to kill

Wasted too much time trying to move to the end, which was disappointing and pretty ridiculous. Seemed like the writer, who wrote so well in the beginning, got tired and just ended it—but it really did not tell us anything.

3 people found this helpful

contains graphic depictions of child rape/torture

What disappointed you about A Tale for the Time Being?

The first half was definitely stellar. Great narrator helped bring to life the ties between two disparate cultures with a gripping plot. I feel greatly misled by this book, however. It contains graphic depictions of attempted child rape and numerous descriptions of torture of a child. There are just somethings that I don't want to have to listen to in the car on the way to work, and those rank highest. I turned it off after I couldn't trust that the descriptions would end. Too bad.

Would you recommend A Tale for the Time Being to your friends? Why or why not?

Certainly not.

What about Ruth Ozeki’s performance did you like?

Her character voices weren't over the top, her cadence and inflection were spot on.

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

Definitely anger.

51 people found this helpful