Both completely foreign and painfully familiar

This wonderful novel manages somehow to be both completely foreign and at the same time painfully familiar. The foreignness is expected; the reader opens the book already knowing that it is about a Pakistani boy named Hayat growing up in America. There are many truly lovely passages that reveal the wisdom of the Quran and the Muslim faith. One section recounting Hayat’s trip to a mosque is performed as a chant in the audio book, was so mesmerizing I felt transported to that holy place. Other passages offered equally fascinating glimpses into daily life in a Pakistani household, with benign accounts of exotic foods and unfamiliar (to me) gender roles.

Underlying these scenes of Muslim religious and domestic life is the universal tale of a child growing up. Here is where the strange becomes familiar. I do not say this because Hayat is growing up in my home town, Milwaukee, but because his struggles are those of any child. Hayat, like many children, misunderstands what is going on around him, he misinterprets, he thinks everything is about him . . . in short, he is a normal kid. Through his eyes, we witness the cruelty borne by women in the name of religion or to protect their children. In a funny passage, we see Hayat learn about sex. In a sickening passage, we see him act out the prejudice he has learned from the adults around him. Most readers will find echoes of themselves in Hayat’s continuing struggle to fit in.

[I read this as an audio book, extremely well-performed by the author]

64 people found this helpful

Learned a complex culture in a story well told.

Would you consider the audio edition of American Dervish to be better than the print version?

I did not read the print version, but I thoroughly enjoyed the audio version. The accents were very real.

What other book might you compare American Dervish to and why?

A book such as Avalon might be comparable with its myriad characters and complex personalities as they attempt to adapt to American culture.

What about Ayad Akhtar’s performance did you like?

His apparent good accent and appropriate intonations called for in the different settings.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Yes

Any additional comments?

If one is seeking knowledge about a Muslim family and the impact of their religion on them and the place where they live? This is a very good book for beginners such as I.

14 people found this helpful

What a sad, tragic, enlightning, memorable tale.

Where does American Dervish rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

Top 10%

What was one of the most memorable moments of American Dervish?

The Muslim cutural enlightning moments and there were many.

What does Ayad Akhtar bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Direct realistic contact with the Muslim axperience.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Hospital scene at the end and the meeting with Nathan right after.

Any additional comments?

The depth of hatred for Jews was something, if true and I'm sure it is, that will probably last as long as there are Arabs like the ones in this book.It's nice to be a person whose life is not ruled by extreme religion. Life is a struggle without that.

11 people found this helpful

Compelling performance and story

This little novel stunned me into immobility,and until I finished the epiloge I was in the world of Pakistani newcomers in the midwest. When I refer to the novel as "little" I am only referring to its length. It is a powerful big story of family, faith, love, hate and all the universal themes that make good fiction the moral compass for the 21st century. I have searched for a novel that could give the reader a look at what it is like to be a Muslim in America. Although that is too large a task for one little Muslim community, it does give the curious a direction to follow.It doesn't suprise me that the reader is the author.This is one of the most riveting performaces I have ever enjoyed. Please read this book.

18 people found this helpful

quite the tale

A different kind of story for me, about any kind of religion let alone the Mulim faith. A coming of age story that was educatioinal and informational for a non-Muslim like me. Still at its core it was a story about human nautre that could've had any setting for a background. They say, whomver they is, that it takes 3 generations for a family of immigrants to fully assimilate into the American culture. I wonder if that's really true?

32 people found this helpful

Excellent insight into an unfamiliar culture

First of all, I was pleasantly surprised at how well the author narrated the book. Often, that doesn't seem to work out so well. I loved his interpretation of his auntie's second husband. What I enjoyed most was the insight that I was afforded into a culture that I am, admittedly, very unfamiliar with. I love the narrators' complicated, troubled parents. Actually, I found all of the characters expertly drawn. I felt that occasionally the narrative relied a little too heavily on high drama, bordering on melodrama at times, but this didn't take away from my overall enjoyment of both the book and the performance.

12 people found this helpful

Amazing Story

This is one of the best books I have read this year! Extremely well written and thought-provoking. The author makes you feel as if you are in the home of the Shah family. I don’t k ow much about the Muslim faith but the story paints a picture of the challenges we all face to understand and follow our beliefs. It is especially poignant from the perspective of an adolescent Young man trying to do the right thing and the harsh reality when he makes the wrong choices.

3 people found this helpful

a complex, rewarding book

What about Ayad Akhtar’s performance did you like?

Because of Mr. Akhtar's background and the fact that he is also a wonderful actor, his performance is completely involving, his accents spot on. You really feel as if you come to know the people inhabiting this book.

Who was the most memorable character of American Dervish and why?

The character of Meena, the

Any additional comments?

This is a book to live in, full of insights and beautifully told. It's one of the best books I've listened to in ages.

10 people found this helpful

Perfect listen - narration, story, characters all five star

Loved this coming of age family drama with themes of religious and ethnic identity. Fast moving plot that manages to also develop complicated, quirky characters and themes. My favorite kind of book. Audio version is narrated by author and its excellent

2 people found this helpful

I loved it!

Where does American Dervish rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

One of my top favorites.

Any additional comments?

I love to read books that expand my worldview by taking me inside another culture. This was a very engrossing, well-written and narrated story, and I loved it. I read and listen to audiobooks a lot on my travels, and I'd definitely recommend this one to others!

8 people found this helpful