Bogged Down By Dystopian Bureaucracy

Any additional comments?

This is almost a complete departure from the mystery and wonder of the first book Annihilation. It was, I hate to say boring. It was basically the story of a man who is something of a spy, but really a lame bureaucrat and his feelings. It is probably an ok book if you like that sort of thing, but I wanted something weirder... I wanted area X.

I gave it three stars which may be a bit generous because A. I like the way the author describes the feeling of what it is like to exist in an environment (whether natural or unnatural), and B: The ending was unexpected and opened up volume three to become awesome again.

9 people found this helpful

Out of Control - Spoiler Free

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Yes, I would recommend this book and it's predecessor, Annihilation. The second installment of the Southern Reach trilogy follows the character, Control, as he attempts to unravel the mysteries of the Southern Reach organization as its new Director. Deep and suspenseful, I found this audiobook keeping me in the car long after I got home from my commute. While Annihilation focused on the inexplicable Area X, Authority adds a cloak and dagger layer to the agency charged with understanding and containing Area X.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Control was a sympathetic character.

Which scene was your favorite?

Whitby. I won't spoil it.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

Find out about our exciting career opportunities at the Southern Reach!

Any additional comments?

I'd categorize this book as a Lovecraftian horror, spy thriller, mystery. It takes an incredibly mundane setting and injects it with so much weird, that you can't help struggling to puzzle out what it all means. But you can't puzzle it out. It resists explanation at every turn. This is actually my fear with the final installment, that the mystery will never be fully revealed or explained, and the reader will be left with so many unanswered questions they will feel disappointed. Make no mistake, this book answers some big questions from the first book. But others just deepen the mystery.

9 people found this helpful

From cosmic horror to office drama.

What a terrible sequel to an incredible first book. Why Vandermeer thought this would be an acceptable or in any way interesting is beyond me. Don’t read this, finish the first and don’t look any further. Because what ever your explanation for Area X is, it’s far more entertaining than what VanderMeer actually delivers.

3 people found this helpful

Not impressive

Would you listen to another book narrated by Bronson Pinchot?

Perhaps. His narration wasn't great, but it wasn't terrible either.

Do you think Authority needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

This book is the second in a trilogy. I enjoyed the first - Annihilation - much more. But with as weak as I felt this book to be I am not sure I will go on to read the final book. This book solves some mysteries, and brings up a lot more, but really didn't leave a strong urge in me to continue reading and figure it all out.

3 people found this helpful

Only good thing here is Mr. Pinchot's narration.

I picked the trilogy because Audible recommended it and did not enjoy anything of it besides Bronson Pinchot's narration in book 2 and 3. The story is incomprehensible and so full of adjectives describing each and every thing that your brain tends to shut off just trying to hurry the story to get to the point. I can't recommend any of the 3 books and feel that they I wasted my credits on all 3.

10 people found this helpful

Another surreal expedition into the uncanny

In Authority, VanderMeer pivots from the first-person journal of the unnamed biologist (read by Carolyn McCormick) which introduced “Area X” in Annihilation to an exploration of a different, though as uncanny and surreal, terrain: the organization which sent her into “Area X” in the first place, the Southern Reach itself. We do see the biologist often in Authority, but it is through the eyes of agent/operative John Rodriguez (aka “Control”), newly appointed acting director of the Southern Reach, interrogating her after her reappearance along with the other survivors of the expedition depicted in Annihilation. Control finds offices in decay and disarray, a shrinking staff divided into factions loyal to the previous director and “lifers” who are in it for the weird science and/or have nowhere else, really, to go. Throughout, Control reports his progress and findings — often couched — to The Voice, a shrouded, mysterious figure known only as a (digitally masked) voice on the phone. The cast of characters here each have layers and motivations — usually inscrutable — of their own: Grace, the assistant director who believes the previous director is still alive; Cheney, the head of the science department; and fellow scientist Whitby, who frequently acts as Control’s guide. I found the Southern Reach in Authority to act as both a metaphor for the many fragments of our own labyrinthine consciousnesses while also a rejection of such abstraction or disaggregation; an organization gone feral after decades of attempting to understand the incomprehensible, having stared too long into the abyss. Meanwhile Control’s expedition into its hierarchies and storage rooms and film archives plays with and against reader expectations: again we must question the reliability of our narrator, of the purpose and use of evidence and rationality in the context of such a narrative in the first place. VanderMeer creates mystery, unease, and an escalation of the compulsion behind this series: what is “Area X”?

Narrated by Bronson Pinchot for Blackstone Audio, the audiobook is, again, fantastic, cementing my feeling that Pinchot is one of the best narrators in the business (from non-fiction like How to Build an Android: The True Story of Philip K. Dick’s Robotic Resurrection to the wide-ranging accents of Tim Powers’ On Stranger Tides and Last Call, to Ray Bradbury’s The Halloween Tree). Pinchot’s characterizations of Grace (annoyed, Southern, mistrustful of Control), Cheney (bombastic, seemingly oblivious), Whitby (hesitant, waffling, couching), linguist Jessica Hsyu, and indeed “Ghost Bird”, the biologist from Annihilation are all spot-on. On the latter it’s really, really interesting to get a third-person perspective on the biologist, who remains a bit flat in affect but with something else waiting underneath. Pinchot also does something a bit subtle in the first chapters: he starts voicing Control’s dialogue with a soft Hispanic accent, which slowly disappears until being read with a neutral accent. Is his identity so quickly swallowed up by the Southern Reach? It’s just one more of the layers-within-layers that draws us ever deeper in. As the sense of unease, of wrongness, of looking where we should not be looking grows (to me drawing connections between the Southern Reach of Authority and the Coburn National Laboratory and Observatory in Robert Jackson Bennett’s American Elsewhere), Pinchot’s narration matches it, tension for tension, finally bursting apart like a puffball mushroom and letting the ideas aloft like spores across the terroir of the transformed landscapes, closing after a novel with a more thriller pacing of half-hour chapters with an extended last chapter three times that length which is impossible to put down. In the end, Authority like Annihilation stands alone; one can read the other without having read (or having to read) the other; reading Authority without Annihilation may if anything add to the mysteriousness at hand, though of course each offers additional layers of context for the other. Also: both novels offer by their final pages a certain closure to dramatic arcs of decision and action, while of course inviting (if not compelling!) further expeditions.

13 people found this helpful

Disappointment

One of the most intriguing settings and plot devices in years - what is Area X? - squandered by a baffling decision to focus on a new boss of the Southern Reach and his personal peccadillos.

I spent 10 hours waiting for it to fulfill a promise made in the previous book. It never did. I’m going to read the next book in the series, not because I’m looking forward to it or because I have any faith that it will deliver an engaging story, but because like Control searching after the Biologist I simply feel the need to see it through.

2 people found this helpful

Weaker than its predecessor, necessary to move on to the next one

Authority wasn’t as engaging as Annihilation for me, because the story was no longer taking place in area x and it’s a third person narrative. I’m all too familiar with the intricacies of the office work environment and didn’t particularly enjoy hearing about it for like 8 hours.

I think the strength of this book was how the author described how intense it was being in this established environment, as an outsider, while it was on the cusp of failure. The anxiety and suspicion that Control felt was relatable and unnerving and made me empathetic to him.

There were absolutely interesting parts of Authority, mainly action-y parts where mysteries about area x were begin to become more clear and concrete as the main character sleuthed around. Authority was almost double the length of Annihilation, I wish it were the other way around.

The reader’s performance was lively.
As a listener, it is helpful to have characters differentiated by voice, but I do question the reader’s performance of two characters of color - Grace and a minor character whose name I can’t remember. The reader’s performance for these two characters seemed like saturated stereotypes for a sassy Black woman and a meek Asian woman. The stereotypes did not add anything to the personalities of the characters - the way they were written and their behavior and things they said supported their characteristics without the stereotypes being so heavily imparted.

1 person found this helpful

Meh

an unnecessary part of the trilogy, as far as I can tell, not a lot of things are resolved

1 person found this helpful

A less than stellar piece of the puzzle

Not as engaging as the first novel but I'm interested to see the next installment. I wouldn't recommend it in itself.

1 person found this helpful