Wow, what book did the other folks listen to?

I'm astonished at the negative reviews that have been published for this book! My experience has been totally different. This is not an Inspector Banks series book and shouldn't be approached as one. Peter Robinson offers a great story with wonderful twists and turns, great characters--and why would you object to hearing what people order in a restaurant? I liked learning about new British beers to try. The performance is good--the voices are pleasant, although Toby Lennet Moore pronounces a few things rather oddly, but that's a personal issue for me and probably wouldn't be noticed by other listeners. Moore does have a fair gift for accents and gives life to characters in that fashion. I also enjoyed the voice of Grace in her diary entries and felt that this convention added depth to the characters and the story.

I'd recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good mystery. Robinson is an intelligent author with a good ear for dialogue and the ability to create interesting characters. He's not always worried bout making his characters perfectly likeable but actually mixes personality aspects in each one that make them richer and more real than a less talented author would be able to achieve.

Don't skip this book because of the negative reviews, please. Make up your own mind!

17 people found this helpful

WOW! Miss Alan Banks, but this was great!

Would you consider the audio edition of Before the Poison to be better than the print version?

As I love the "Kings" English as it was meant to be spoken, loved every word.

What did you like best about this story?

Really enjoyed the entire book. I have always enjoyed Mr Robinson's character developement. Discriptions of the country side, the house, weather,and insite into a nurse's experiance in WW ll while based in Indonesia was fascinating

What does Susan Lyons and Toby Lennet Moore bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Once again the the beauty of the language, the way it should be spoken.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

A wonderful story of love, loss, and interesting people.

Any additional comments?

Just relax and enjoy everything from Yorkshire to Capetown.

6 people found this helpful

Drivel . . . utter drivel

What disappointed you about Before the Poison?

I have enjoyed all of the Inspector Banks books and find it hard to believe this is written by the author of that series.

The plot is less than compelling and entirely predictable. And, why oh why do we have to know what every character orders every time they eat at a pub or restaurant? Not only are we told the name of a wine they drink, we also learn that it tastes of currents with an undertone of tobacco. When the protagonist shops for CD's in South Africa, we are given a list of all of his purchases. Each course of every meal eaten at home is also detailed. All of this information does nothing to advance the plot or to give us a deeper understanding of the characters.

Although I've never read a romance novel, I suspect that the love scenes in this book are better suited to a book from that genre. Here, they are just icky.

What do you think your next listen will be?

I just hope it's better than the last two I've listened to.

Would you be willing to try another one of Susan Lyons and Toby Lennet Moore ’s performances?

I'll never listen to a Toby Lennet Moore narration again. The story is told from a first-person perspective, and his voicing of the protagonist only makes him more annoying.

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

Severe disappointment.

14 people found this helpful

Boring story, big disappointment to this PR fan

What disappointed you about Before the Poison?

The story went nowhere. Don't want to write a spoiler, but there's no

What could Peter Robinson have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?

I'm a big PR fan. I wish the story had been about Alan Banks, but I do understand that writers get tired of doing the same old same old. This character, however, was just boring and unlikeable. As were all the other characters in the book. WAY too much minute detail (who ordered what for dinner, which wine, which brandy, holy crap these people drink a lot). It felt like filler and I commented to friend that Robinson must have had a word quota he was trying to meet. Not up to his usual standard.

Did the narration match the pace of the story?

No, the narration by the male was awful. The woman, Susan Lyons, was fabulous. She was the saving grace of the audiobook and after hearing her, I went in search of her other audio work.

What character would you cut from Before the Poison?

All of them!

14 people found this helpful

Before the Poision

I really enjoyed this book. It encompassed so many aspects of human life, and man's ability to adapt to all situations.
Both the readers did a wonderful job of narration. I hope to hear their voices on many more recordings.
I would say to anyone who is a Peter Robinson fan, this is one of his best.

1 person found this helpful

Try it, you'll like it

If the mystery had been, read this book, guess who wrote it, I would have said Kate Morton. If you like her, you will enjoy this book. It's that kind of story. The characters are likeable, you care about what happens, and even though it is almost fourteen hours, I felt like it ended too soon.

GREAT READ

So different from the Alan Banks series but very interesting and beautifully written. Throughly enjoy anything by Peter Robinson

Relaxing mystery?

Isolated house. Old murder site. Ghosts, nightmares and scary sounds in the night. Started strong. But all works out nicely without tension or danger. A bit too relaxing although I liked the narration

Highly unsatisfactory plot and denouement

Gagged on some of the trite, touristy phrases. I guess the author thought he was being cute ... he just came over as shallow and banal. Another ‘ugly American’ strikes again.

returning this book

It was recommended at the end of either an Ian Rutledge mystery, or James Herriot: "If you enjoyed this book....." so I gaveit a try. I did not like the graphic execution at the start of the book, nor values of rich and famous protagonist, and I did not like the pace of the reader, and the story was not of interest to me.