Ibby Bell & The Big House

This a coming of age sothern tale about Ibby Bell a 12yr old simply dropped off by her mothers to live with Ms. Fanny. Southern life is nothing like the North and that summer Ibby learns a lesson she will never forget. 5 🌟 performance & storyline. The perfect southern story for a quiet rainy day. Narration 5 🌟 by January Lavoy. Well worth your credit.

Official DeAnn DeVille Review: Narrator, Writer, Audiobook Review Blogger , Mom

23 people found this helpful

Don't miss this one!

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

This is a powerful story, well-written. I couldn't stop listening!

What other book might you compare Dollbaby to and why?

It reminds me of THE HELP and Sue Monk Kidd's THE SECRET LIFE OF BEES. Totally engaging, a sense of being in the world the author portrays.

What about January Lavoy’s performance did you like?

She's a good narrator, with a nice voice and a real talent for accents and inflections.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

It touched me very deeply.

16 people found this helpful

Great Story

What made the experience of listening to Dollbaby the most enjoyable?

Loved it.

What other book might you compare Dollbaby to and why?

It really puts you in the Old South.

What does January Lavoy bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

I always enjoy January Lavoy's narration.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

It's relatable for anyone who has trouble with her mother.

11 people found this helpful

Disappointing

After reading the reviews and description I had hopes for this book but sadly it didn’t make it. The story isn’t new. Orphaned/unwanted/abandoned/mistreated child is delivered into the hands of an eccentric Southern relative(s) where love grows and the child comes of age under the quiet oversight of the kindly, loyal black house help. It has been told by more skilled word crafters and in the voices of much more developed and memorable characters. That is but one of many issues I have. The book overflows with clichés, the most annoying of which is the ridiculous collection of names. We in the south do, on occasion name people things like Anne and Joe and Elizabeth. You wouldn’t know that from this book. Nor would you know that every African American does not have a colorful (and borderline racist) nickname. There were plot lines that initially caught my interest but they were never developed or were given quick treatment they became irrelevant (Apparently had Atticus Finch given Mayella Ewell a good stern talking to he could have resolved the whole false rape accusation thing in a matter of a chapter) And speaking of Atticus, I wonder how this book sits with African American readers. There are scenes of sit-ins and lip service to the civil rights movement but no evidence any of it---even taking part in it--- impacted of any of the central black characters or changed the way they relate to the whites. Stereotypes are everywhere and the take away lesson is that while we are "family" we still eat in the kitchen. Even the book’s big final reveal manages to evoke a subtle, uncomfortable racism while never actually addressing the racial issues it attempts to challenge. Some of this is bad writing, some bad editing and some just bad ideas. It’s too bad, it could have been an okay book, probably better tailored to a young adult audience. As it is the story has been told many times with a lot more skill.

38 people found this helpful

Tale of Old-New Orleans Well Paced

First off, Doll-Baby is superbly narrated. January LaVoy masterfully adapts her reading to her characters' personalities and origins. This definitely gives the story depth and adds flesh to the bones of the individuals in the tale.

The story itself is good… it holds your interest, but Ms. McNeal often stunts her tale by a too simplistic sentence structure, which leaves the listener hoping for slightly more depth in the thought and personalities of her characters. Ms. LaVoy helps to add gradations of personal qualities which Ms. McNeal often neglects. Hence the three stars for the story itself and the five stars given the performance.

Some listeners may find the characters somewhat stereotyped. But in Ms. McNeal's defense, this seems to be a matter of the depths to which she wished to mine her players' inner life. Also, all of her characters are treated to the same level of development, which does give the story an even literary treatment. In other words, there isn't a lack of development in only some of the characters, there seems to be an overall reliance by Ms. McNeal to have the reader fill in the undefined gaps on all of her characters, while mainly giving a surface development to them all. That said, you do actually get enough grit in the story to get to know the players and to care what happens to them.

If you are interested in a (non-intellectually-taxing,) solid story of a young girl's coming-of-age in unexpected circumstances, you will enjoy Doll-Baby overall, at about that four-star level.

Just don't expect to discover the next Great American Novel.

14 people found this helpful

A joy to listen to

Enter a doorway to another time and place, you'll be sorry when it is over! Wonderful story and fantastic narration, loved this gem!

6 people found this helpful

I Want to Meet All of Them!

Would you listen to Dollbaby again? Why?

Again...and again...and again! In fact, one i reached the end i wanted to start over. The characters were each so unique and the narration was perfect.

What did you like best about this story?

The story itself. It kept giving little surprises. Like each room of the house, each chapter brought a new secret and discovery of it's own.

What about January Lavoy’s performance did you like?

Subtle differences in her pitch and accent made it easy to recognize which character was speaking. I enjoyed her narration very much.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

I don't want to give anything away, but Queenie's reaction to her loss was incredibly moving.

Any additional comments?

This kind of story makes me want to write a book. It makes me want to travel back to my hometown, wander around... in... and through the little house i grew up in, and write MY story. Maybe i will.....:) Thank you Laura McNeal for a story i will never forget.

6 people found this helpful

Trite story, stereotyped characters

Good narration but a terrible, trite, melodramatic plot and stereotypical characters. A waste of time unless you like Southern soap opera. Yuck !

11 people found this helpful

Enjoyable but not great.

Would you try another book from Laura Lane McNeal and/or January Lavoy?

Yes, this was an interesting story with some well rounded characters. Some the events & characters were predictable but it was still entertaining,

Would you recommend Dollbaby to your friends? Why or why not?

Yes, as an easy read and as long as they are not looking for something deep or socially changing.

Do you think Dollbaby needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

Not really.

3 people found this helpful

A decent story badly told

What disappointed you about Dollbaby?

I couldn't get past the first 45 minutes. It's full of canned personalities and paper thin plot lines lifted from better novels.

What do you think your next listen will be?

I'm not sure I trust Audible suggestions after this one.

Would you be willing to try another one of January Lavoy’s performances?

No. Her voice is pleasing but her style is too dramatic and commercial. I don't enjoy the baby voice treatment for the younger character. It's distracting and irritating.
The characters of Queenie and Baby Doll are poorly written and not the narrator's fault but her reading amplifies the stereotyped dialogue.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

It might appeal to a book club for ladies in the 80+ age range who want to read about New Orleans and want an easy read. It is sweet, unchallenging and predictable.

11 people found this helpful