Hard to understand with the accent

The story was a good one with solid characters and a touching plot. What was incredibly distracting was the narrator. When she was reading normally, it was easy to follow along but when she would try to do different voices, I had to almost ALWAYS replay that part. I even slowed the speed down at one point to try to understand. It just became something that interfered with the story far more than it should have.

30 people found this helpful

Not for me

I’m sure this is a lovely book IF you can understand the thick accent. Listening to a book isn’t meant to be this difficult. I only lasted 4 chapters and I was done.

21 people found this helpful

Close To Perfection--A Definite Thumbs Up!

The publisher gives a great summary. Most of the other reviewers concur with my judgment that this is a must-read story that you just won't ever forget. Truly delightful but with a big dab of the bittersweet. Yes, it has some tough emotional moments but that is what makes it multi-dimensional and wonderful.

Who is Eleanor Oliphant? She keeps to herself, preferring her own company in all situations. She is prim and proper, has strong beliefs about good manners and such. She dresses a bit oddly, probably looks like your dowdy old aunt, but is in fact, a young lady. Eleanor has experienced very little of life, at least, its good parts. Her childhood has been very dark and she is still dominated by Mommy, whom she talks with every week. Eleanor is very intelligent yet could be described as a self-contained island.

But things are about to change, starting with a bikini wax--OUCH! And more importantly, an IT guy with sloppy clothing and even poorer hygiene, who somehow worms his way into Eleanor's life after they both observe an elderly gentleman fall and injure himself on the sidewalk by work. The two come to his rescue--Eleanor would have ignored the incident but is guilted into becoming involved by co-worker, Raymond.

That is really all you need to know about this audiobook. It is best to go into this story with as little information as possible and enjoy it as the surprises unfold.

After a slowish start, I became mesmerized and couldn't get the story out of my head. I didn't want to stop listening and yet I didn't want to finish it, either.

Narration was perfection. How lucky for author Honeyman to get such a talented performer as McCarron to read her first novel.

This is one of the good ones, folks. Don't miss it!

345 people found this helpful

Please be warned

This story is extremely dark. It is a lurking, creeping kind of dark. It is excellently written and narrated, don't get me wrong, but if I had known how hard it was, I'd have opted for a different title. I have enough hard in my own life right now, this about set me over the edge. Just a warning for other sensitive souls out there.

859 people found this helpful

Completely fine? No... Completely AWESOME

I wasn't sure about this book at first. Started a bit slow for me. However, it turned out to be completely engaging. You find yourself rooting for Eleanor, laughing at her faux pas and being completely enamored with her. I found myself tearing up more than once during this story. This is a wonderful story of how a person with a difficult past can evolve, grow and become who they are truly meant to be. Raymond is a solid character who guides Eleanor on her path to being who she has always wanted and needed to be. This is an absolutely excellent book. I listen to my audio books while commuting and found myself not wanting to get out of the car on several occasions.

337 people found this helpful

Orphanages Vs. Foster Care

This is a story about a woman who suffered from something tragic as a child and was abused/neglected by her mother who I'd argue suffered from mania or a sever mental disorder. She was haunted by her past and never given the resources she needed to properly cope and grieve her situation. It took me back to an adolescent psychology course I took in university that focused on attachment theory in children raised in foster care vs. orphanages. Eleanor mentioned that the moment something went left of center, she was shipped off to the next foster home or handed off to the next social worker. The lack of long term relationship made Eleanor incapable of normal interaction and made it impossible for anyone to notice that she needed help.

15 people found this helpful

Eleanor sneaks up on you

I admit to struggling with this book at the beginning - - Eleanor just felt like such a bitter pill to swallow, but brilliantly, and I mean BRILLIANTLY, the author snuck her right into my heart. Aided by one of the best narrators ever, that slow build into caring meant that by the time all of Eleanor is revealed I was so tied into her life that when the book ended I felt like I was waving goodbye to a family member. Now that's good writing, and this is an amazing book. Please don't be like me and dismiss it too quickly. By the end you and Eleanor will both be fine.

205 people found this helpful

Top 10 Best Books Ever Read

The narrator was perfectly suited to this wonderfully written book. We all know an odd duck like Eleanor Oliphant, but we often don't consider what kind of life leads to the way they are. This story is very funny a lot of the time, but there is a darkness creeping around the edges. Brilliantly narrated--would love to see this made into a movie.

133 people found this helpful

A wonderful read with a heroine you root for

What about Cathleen McCarron’s performance did you like?

Cathleen McCarron did an excellent job with the narration. The only thing I would criticize was the Scottish accent she gave to Eleanor's coworkers in the beginning of the book. It was so affected that I could barely follow the conversation and it almost put me off reading the rest for fear I wouldn't be able to understand the accents. Luckily, that was just a tiny moment of the book and the narration for the rest was wonderful.

Any additional comments?

I was so pleasantly surprised by this book! I often find that literature that is set in the present time and culturally relevant at the time of its publication has a way of feeling fleeting and immediately stale. This was most certainly not the case here! Though it interspersed a few occasional pop culture and modern societal references, Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine is a book that could survive the test of time. The main reason, I think, is that it is not a story of the present; it is a story that simply happens to be set in the present. Eleanor Oliphant is really a story of human nature and emotion.

Eleanor is a phenomenal character. I was invested in learning more about her from the very beginning. I didn't initially know what to expect of Eleanor's character and my first thoughts were that the book would end up being a story about some kind of sociopath. Eleanor does possess some characteristics that fit the bill. However, as the story went on I went from being morbidly interested to falling in love with her as a character. Her development was, in my opinion, flawless.

Eleanor's journey is beautifully illustrated. It is an emotional journey for the reader as well. We follow her from a life of mundane mere-existence, to one of delusion - in which she would like to live, but does not yet have the courage - and in which the meager beginnings of a real life are hardly noticed by her. And then, slowly, she begins to try living somewhere in the middle of that, before reality strikes and she falls from the top of the small hill she has scaled, down far past where she started, to complete rock bottom. And in the end we get to watch her discover joy and blossom in every aspect of life. And as a reader, I was rooting for her every step of the way and willing her to make it through.

The way that Eleanor's demons and struggles and inadequacies slowly come to light is nothing short of brilliant. Although the entirety of Eleanor's traumatic past is never revealed until the final few pages, bits and pieces are masterfully woven into the story - subtly, with hints and small details here and there, just enough so that we are able to put it together but have not been patronized with overtness. And this works so perfectly because when Eleanor's story finally comes out, we are simply letting out our breath - not for assuaged curiosity, for we already know - but because we have been holding it for Eleanor and realize what that revelation means to her and for her. And that is what is so perfect about it. The ending was about Eleanor - just Eleanor - and her ultimate healing after an unbelievable journey.

This was a beautiful story about brokenness, coping (and lack thereof), growing, and becoming whole again, or for the first time. Eleanor's journey included learning some of what most would consider the fundamentals of what it means to be human - to be loved, and to love in return. To follow her journey was so greatly rewarding and an uplifting reminder of what we can overcome as people - particularly in regards to the past. Five stars!!

74 people found this helpful

Outstanding

I LOVED this book! I loved the characters, particularly Eleanor, and gentle Raymond. Made me cry and laugh. Didn't want it to end....

49 people found this helpful