Hard Country lives up to it's title.

This is the best book I have listened to in over a year. My husband is the lover of coyboy stories, but this sounded interesting so I decided to give it a try. Don't let the lenght of the book deter you, I wanted more.
The characters are really well developed, the writer and narrator give you a real feel for the times and country. This is no place for wimps and thouchy-feely types, rather tough, stoic, deal with the situation and move on types. Which is not to say there is no friendship or love for characters. Quite the opposite, the story shows how love, loyalty and friendship bridge the years.
The story runs from the mid 1800's to WWI, chronicling the changes in the country side, towns coming and going, and inventions (electricity/ cars). The characters are so real, and the narration is superb. I will definitely look for more books narrated by George Guidall.

78 people found this helpful

Move over Lonesome Dove!

Having recently done all but one of the modern Kerney series I wasn't sure what to expect. Such rich storytelling by George Guidall relaying the drama of just trying to exist just made me appreciate life as we have it now all the more. I used to want things like this to be turned into movies or series. In this case I almost think it would just somehow be less. Maybe Kevin Costner could do it. Following these characters through their lives and seeing how childhood lessons/events played out through adulthood and how promising lives didn't always live out (or up) to promise is just priceless. I was about to start this when Mr. McGarrity said there'd be a third before he revisits Kevin Kerney. I wasn't excited about that. Now I am and I am happy to wait for both as I start Backlands.

23 people found this helpful

A fine tribute to New Mexico

What did you love best about Hard Country?

Mr McGarrity did outstanding job of research in New Mexico history and seamlessly wove it into his plot. His characters ring true - with all their strength and flaws. I love the way he portrays strong women. I recognize my father in his gentle hard working people of Tularosa and my mother (a Canadian), a World War II veteran nurse- another strong woman of character - who met ( and later married) my father in that war. His descriptions of the geography and weather of New Mexico. The way he used Eugene Manlove Rhodes in his story was great. The hard life of the ranchers was very well portrayed as well as the Mescalero Indians.

I was fortunate to meet Mr. McGarrity when he spoke and read the first chapter of this book in Alamogordo, NM. It is my understanding it was the first of 3 books. I look forward to the rest and thank him for all his hard work on this book.

What other book might you compare Hard Country to and why?

I've heard people compare it to Lonesome Dove - but they are wrong - it stands alone and will become the new benchmark. It is a cut above.

Have you listened to any of George Guidall’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Yes, he does a fine job of narrating this tale.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

I don't think a movie would cut it. It needs to be a mini series.

Any additional comments?

This book is a tribute to all New Mexicans.

39 people found this helpful

Hard country, but an easy listen

Every so often, I like to listen to an old fashioned western, complete with cowboys, cattle drives, and gun slingers. This was a great choice. Good story, well narrated, and an easy listen. If you like books like Lonesome Dove and that genre, you'll like this. So "jingle your spurs", download, and enjoy.

17 people found this helpful

boring

👎 every time that you get interested in a character they die, you get used to it. I bought it because it has a good narrator, WRONG.

4 people found this helpful

The old west

In my book McGarrity made the west come alive as well as McMurrtry did with his Lonesome Dove series. I am within a couple of hours of finishing this book and felt compelled to write my review now while I have a few minutes. I have enjoyed every second of this book. I am likely to go broke buying the rest of this series if the second book is as good as this one. I suspect my bank account is doomed. This book is a classic in all the right places. Intrigue, sadness, joy, all the right things. Having George Guidall as the narrator is without a doubt a very wise choice. He has a way of making any book come to life. A very enjoyable book.

9 people found this helpful

Enjoyed it!

What made the experience of listening to Hard Country the most enjoyable?

I enjoyed Michael McGarrity's new book. It's different than his other books--following a family in New Mexico in the 1800's and early 1900's. The ending left me wondering if there will be a sequel. George Guidall is a wonderful narrator.

13 people found this helpful

Engrossing historical fiction of the Tularosa area

I loved this book in part because I live in Southwest New Mexico and the novel is based on real historical figures from Pat Garrett to Eugene Rhodes. The description of the Tularosa Basin before it was overgrazed was so accurate - also known as the short grass prairie - it is gone now because of drought and overgrazing. The ranching descriptions are dead-on. The people who settled this country fell in love with the mountains and valleys and despite often incredible hardships made a living. I also appreciated the fact that this was not just about the Anglos (white men and women) who settled the area but also brought to life the roles of the early Hispanic settlers, Buffalo soldiers and Apaches. New Mexico is a land rich in history and cultural diversity and Michael McGarrity makes it come alive. Bravo also to George Guidall whose narration is terrific.

11 people found this helpful

Just not very...

Story covers quite a time line. There is so much detail given to clarify the times, the story gets lost. Overall it was, in my opinion, just not very interesting, not very engaging, not very tied together, just not too very...

2 people found this helpful

Depressing

If you want a book that is a joy to read, get something else.
You keep hoping they grow up and do better but they keep getting worse and keep holding grudges.
Should have been named “The Vindictive Country “.

5 people found this helpful