Worth every minute

What made the experience of listening to KL: A History of the Nazi Concentration Camps the most enjoyable?

This was a daunting effort: 31 hours of the history of the concentration camps. It is NOT a collection of nothing but horror stories. It clarifies and explains the three stages of the camps I, at least, had never thought about.

Who was your favorite character and why?

You don't have characters in histories: you do have personages. None of the admins of the camps are very admirable. This is, you understand, an understatement.

Have you listened to any of Paul Hodgson’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Nope, never heard any of his work. He has an interesting approach to accents. I don't know if his natural speech is German accented or not, but the entire book is done with that accent. Except for the quotations, even short ones, done with a Polish accent, or the one or two American voices done in flawless "American." It seems to be an odd choice for the narration of a history.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Good grief, no! Thirty-one hours in one sitting? Focused on German concentration camps? I listened to the whole thing over a period of a month, and was able to absorb the information. There was enough new-to-me information that I needed time to sift through it.

Any additional comments?

Wachsmann has managed to take an incredible history and make it comprehensible, a gargantuan undertaking. On the whole, beautifully done.

36 people found this helpful

Forget The Reviews. Just Read It.

I almost did not read this book because of accent critiques in the reviews. What nonsense. The German accents make up maybe 5 minutes of a 30+ hour book.
This is the 5th book on German atrocities I have read this year, but shockingly I did not know maybe 98% of the info contained here.
My biggest shock comes from realizing how few people, groups, governments, nationalities, militaries, and even judges were truly innocent and free of guilt. One could even say many of the Jews were killed by Jews themselves., because of the pervasiveness and perversity of it all.

9 people found this helpful

An Oustanding History and A Must Read

This book is a remarkable achievement and if you are interested in the subject at all you will learn a great deal from it, regardless of whatever you already know, You will likely also listen to it more than once. This comprehensive history brings together the many aspects of the KL and draws from extensive German historical research that is unknown to English only readers. The narrator's attempt at voices is odd, but is hardly a reason to not purchase this book. Other narrators say "Quote" and "Unquote" at the end of a quote and some people find that distracting. I suspect the KL narrator's use of a "voice" is a way around that issue. Quotes are rare in KL anyway so it's hardly a distraction although it may catch a listener unaware the first time.

26 people found this helpful

Narrator warning!

I've not finished listening to this yet, but wanted to warn people thinking about buying it in advance, in case the sample doesn't make it clear. The book's amazing, probably unbeatable scholarship, and the narrator's generally good for a non-fiction reader (some of them are very bad), but he makes a really baffling decision to read all quotations - and there are many - in the accents "appropriate" to the person writing/speaking. So chilling stories are somewhat undermined by comedy German...

43 people found this helpful

I Am Grateful For The Narrator

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Yes, but only to those who want to learn more about World War II and can handle this long grim detailed recount.

What was one of the most memorable moments of KL: A History of the Nazi Concentration Camps?

I got a huge sense of renewed interest when the topic of the book switched to human experiments in the KL. Before listening to this audio book I have always assumed this aspect of it was pure science fiction.

What does Paul Hodgson bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Before I got this audio book I read the reviews and noticed a lot of people warning or shunning the narrator for doing this various accents throughout the book. I found his pace, tone, and pronunciations to be spot on. Some of his accents were better than others (I was surprised how well his American accent was). I did not find that it took away from the seriousness or tone of the book, but considered it more of an enhancement. I was able to easily identify which parts of the text were direct quotes and who was being quoted. I am a bit ashamed to admit that was one quote towards the end of the book that actually made me laugh, but after hearing 29 hours of torturous recounts of the going-on's of the KL it was a welcome change.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

The book was a huge eye-opener for me about that time in history. As a result I did research online and watched a few KL-related movies to get a more personal view of what went on. The content of this book will definitely be on my mind for a long time to come and has permanently altered my view of the world.

Any additional comments?

The content of the book is a tough pill to swallow and with it being over 31 hours long I don't know if I would have been able to get through it without the great narration of Paul Hodgson. Stick it out to the end and you will be grateful you did.

6 people found this helpful

Well performed, but...

This is exhaustively researched, and thorough. It adds new information and context, which seems unreal, given the number of books on this topic. That said, if you aren't a scholar it is a bit much, a seemingly endless list of abuses and massacres.

Important, to be sure, but not for the layman.

20 people found this helpful

Excellent, but...

Any additional comments?

The book is excellent, and the narrator does a very good job with the text (although his delivery is perhaps a bit fast), but the accents he uses when reading quotations are very distracting. I found it a very strange choice to read the quotations in the speakers' native accents, not all of which the narrator can do very well, and it detracted from the overall content for me. However, the book is outstanding, and I would still recommend it to anyone interested in the topic.

5 people found this helpful

Well done account of sad history

Excellent history of sad times in humanity's development. The statistics are sometimes overwhelming but the are necessary for understanding how widespread the evil was.

11 people found this helpful

Ridiculous stereotypes

Where does KL: A History of the Nazi Concentration Camps rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

KL: History of the Nazi Concentration Camps is a highly interesting and well-written account of how the Nazis constructed a horrendous instrument of terror and repression.

What was one of the most memorable moments of KL: A History of the Nazi Concentration Camps?

The most memorable moments are, unfortunately, Paul Hodgson's ridiculous imitations of a German accent.

Would you be willing to try another one of Paul Hodgson’s performances?

Paul Hodgson is clearly a talented performer. Unfortunately, however, he - or someone else - has decided that he should read quotations from letters and diaries found in the book with a "German" accent. The result can only be described as utter disaster. Rather than creating a feeling of authenticity, the phony accent turns the performance into tasteless parody. The performance would have scored much higher if the performer had read the quotations in his normal voice.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Not applicable.

20 people found this helpful

Like a textbook

This book is certainly a valuable tool, however it really dropped the ball in a lot of ways. The book has no clear path or direction and hops around from one thing to another without tying them together very well. Would be useful if you were doing a research paper but not for much else

7 people found this helpful