A Wonderful Re-Imagining of Mrs. Keckley's Life

If you could sum up Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker in three words, what would they be?

Vivid
Detailed
Fast-paced

Who was your favorite character and why?

Mrs. Lincoln was my favorite character in this story. I knew so little of her story after her husband was assassinated and she left the White House. So much of her misery was of her own making, but the disrespect with which she was treated after President Lincoln's murder was completely unnecessary. Her legacy has been much maligned by people who did not know her, or people who did know her that were jealous of her. The fact that she struggled in such a human way with her grief. . . not only of her husband's murder, but also the deaths of her two sons. . . was poignant and deeply touching. I'm not sure that I would have been able to act any differently had it been my husband and son.

Have you listened to any of Christina Moore’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

n/a

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

I was struck by the moment in which President Lincoln addressed the crowds in the evening after the war's conclusion from the White House window. The comment that he could be shot by anyone in the crowd made me think about how accessible he was the people and how that is so different from today.

Any additional comments?

This is definitely a story based in historical documents, so if you are not interested in the details, this is not the story for you. However, I will say that so much of whether I like an audiobook is based on how well I like the performer, and you cannot go wrong with Christina Moore's characterization of people in this story. It is subtle, beautifully done, and not overwrought.

39 people found this helpful

New point of view

What made the experience of listening to Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker the most enjoyable?

The narrator did a great job with all the different character's, both male and female. Cadance and rhythm of voice was even and easy to listen to. The book itself is very well written with great detail and visual information, making you feel as if you were there.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker?

I hate to state the obvious, but the assassination of Mr. Lincoln. Not the shooting itself but the reaction of Mrs. Lincoln for weeks/months after. It was very sad to witness her grief through Mrs. Keckley's eyes and point of view.

Which character – as performed by Christina Moore – was your favorite?

Although Mrs. Keckley is the narrator of the story, I found Mrs. Lincoln fascinating. It didn't depict her as "crazy" as we usually hear but as a very insecure, lonely character who deeply loved her husband and who had already lost 2 of her sons before her husband. Her best and only friend was Mrs. Keckley, her freed African American dressmaker. I got the impression that she trusted very few people and would push others away before she could get hurt. That explained a lot of her manic/depressive behavior.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Not extreme. I just enjoyed it and found I missed hearing it after it was over. I was surprised by the ending. I also was very surprised how the entire country turned their back on Mrs. Lincoln after her husband's death. That was sad too.

Any additional comments?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book-story, narrator, delivery.

27 people found this helpful

A different , authentic view of history!!

Elizabeth Keckley was a former slave who earned her own freedom, and her son's, by sewing clothes. Her son, George, was conceived when Elizabeth was enslaved and her master raped her. But George was very dear to her anyway, and as the story opens, he is attending college in Ohio. Elizabeth has set up her business in Washington, DC in the 1860's, working out of a 'colored boardinghouse' , where Elizabeth had lots of friends. Her reputation soon has her making dresses for the DC elite.

When the Lincoln's come to the White House, Elizabeth becomes Mrs. Lincoln's dressmaker, confidant, and apparently her only true friend. As Elizabeth comes and goes in the White House she becomes acquainted with everyone there , including the President, for whom she has great respect and hopes as becoming the "Great Emancipator".

The very intimate and interesting story chronicles the Civil War and the Lincoln family from Elizabeth's unique perspective. Tales of battles, huge death tolls, and political intrigue are interesting in and of themselves. The interaction of Elizabeth with Mary Todd Lincoln also gives a fairly well balanced tale of a President's wife who was often depressed, angry, compulsively shopping for the White House or personal items, and grief stricken with her son's and husband's deaths. One of the most interesting periods came after the death of Abraham Lincoln when Mary Todd was on a campaign to get support as the former President's wife, especially since she was in great debt because of her massive spending sprees.

Life for freedman, through Elizabeth's eyes, before abolishment of slavery, was especially interesting. Also,the roll of 'colored people' trying to enlist in the army, plus the result of hoards of newly freed slaves coming into Washington with nothing to keep them alive, nor any means to support themselves, was even more interesting. Elizabeth's life and actions, as a real person in history, made for fascinating reading as she interacted with Mrs. Lincoln as well as her own people. Excellent reading for everyone wanting a balanced accounting of that period of history!

25 people found this helpful

Mrs. Keckley knew the Lincolns!

Civil War, backstabbing cabinet, difficult wife, dying children.... If I could invite 10 people, living or dead, to dinner, Mr. Lincoln would certainly be one of them and Elizabeth Keckley loved him too. She is the subject of this book and was an intimate member of the Lincoln White House and visited there frequently. I am so impressed with her accomplishments and her ability to navigate the Lincolns' life and many other high level Washingtonians at this time in history. She was clearly an extraordinary woman, if somewhat naive, and I am happy that Jennifer Chiaverini took the time to research and evaluate her importance in the Lincolns' lives. If you are a student of history, especially the Lincolns, you will love this book. The narrator, Christina Moore, is really good.

21 people found this helpful

Good mix of fiction and history

Who knew that at the time of great contention over slavery that Mary Lincoln's best friend was an African American seamstress? This book was obviously well researched and included a good bit of the author's imagination, a combination which made for an outstanding novel. While most of this author's books have been designed for quilters, this novel will appeal to a broader audience. Really enjoyed this one and may listen to it again.

17 people found this helpful

Interesting, for a short story...

Although the perspective was interesting, I would've liked more interaction with the rest of the characters. The small snippets with the President were just a tease. If this dressmaker truly was a witness to historic moments, it would've been fascinating to hear/read more (even if it is fictional) of that experience. Unfortunately, he was just a passing character for most of the book... Mrs. Lincoln just got to be annoying toward the end and I just wanted it to be over.

13 people found this helpful

I couldn't get through it

This book wasn’t for you, but who do you think might enjoy it more?

I usually enjoy historical fiction, but it was very slow and monotone. I had to listen to the same chapter three times, as my interest kept wanning

What do you think your next listen will be?

The Third Bullet

What didn’t you like about Christina Moore’s performance?

very slow-monotone,

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

the concept for the story is good-may be better in paper

12 people found this helpful

Just an OK read

Is there anything you would change about this book?

The description of this story led me to believe that it would be an engaging, insightful story about Mrs. Lincoln and her dressmaker. It felt more like a very long lecture in a history class. There were way too many facts and not enough storytelling. The characters lacked a true connection and though the story seemed thoroughly researched, it didn't keep my attention. I finished it simply because I bought it, not because I was really interested in it.

If you’ve listened to books by Jennifer Chiaverini before, how does this one compare?

First one I've read and probably my last.

What about Christina Moore’s performance did you like?

Always enjoy Christina Moore. She is a fantastic narrator.

9 people found this helpful

Fell Short In Narration, Story Development

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

No. This book looked promising as I'm always interested in historical novels. I wasn't in love with the narrator when I bought it but hoped the story would be interesting enough to carry her. Alas, it fell short all the way around. So short that I dreaded going on my daily walk knowing I had this book waiting for me. I stopped listening about halfway thru - I realized I was avoiding my walk because of this story. Life's too short to listen to 7 more hours of drone, fake-y voices.

What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?

Well,probably most interesting was the fact that an ex slave could sew for The First Lady. I'd hoped to learn more about Mrs Lincoln, her clothing and how an ex slave could build such a great dressmaking business. But it either was so poorly narrated that my mind wandered and/or story not developing that I gave up.

How could the performance have been better?

Get a different narrator. Her voices made mockeries of the characters. And it was hard to tell who was speaking. She was boring but also lacking in the ability to bring the characters to life and make them memorable.

Do you think Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

I don't know, as I never finished the book.

Any additional comments?

I just won't buy anytHing with this narrator anymore.

5 people found this helpful

Good history

Where does Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

This book rates in the upper 3/4 of my listening

What was one of the most memorable moments of Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker?

History - the freedom of slaves, at least for a while! Also the friendship that was formed between a very lonely person and her dependable dressmaker.

What does Christina Moore bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

A very good reader that makes you want to listen more. Her ability to emphasize important information but also to have a kindness and empathy in her voice.

If you could take any character from Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker out to dinner, who would it be and why?

Elizabeth - I would like to learn her art from her, but also just sit and ask questions and listen to her experiences.

Any additional comments?

I think the author does her history research and homework very well before she starts writing.

5 people found this helpful