You are the proverbial 'fly on the wall' ...

In one review or another, the reviewer said, to my astonishment, that the prologue had given away the whole story ... as if it were a fiction novel. Not about this book, but another true crime book. I looked at those words in bewilderment. This is True Crime, not a suspense novel.

This book is so well done that it feels like a suspense novel. It puts you right in there with the family. Some True Crime books are told through the eyes of the police, the prosecutors or the lawyers. This book puts you more right in the midst of the family. For myself, I marveled at Elaine's incredible strength of character, love, resolve. She is not a heroine in a fictional novel, but a real woman who suffered a terrible series of tragedies but never felt sorry for herself. I think I should love to photograph her one day. Her eyes must hold the spectrum of emotions only visible in those with heart, strength, love, resolve.

Kevin Pierce is a fine narrator. His voice lets you imagine the entire scene. I have many of the books he has narrated.

Yes, I do like reading paper books...very much...but without these audio books, I'd never get a chance to go out walking for 4 miles without boredom. But I think I will have to start getting the Kindle editions as well because I want to see the spelling of the names and places.

Jack Olsen has taken facts and woven a fine tapestry. He does not sensationalize this awful deed, but he does not marginalize it either. His point of view is not pounded into your head. Only a fool would not share how Brenda foiled another prior attempt (I won't clarify).

I'm old and my memory is not that good. Don't feel sorry for me because it has its advantages. Next year I can listen to the book again as if it were the first time! :)

Enjoy the mastery of a true wordsmith with this True Crime book.

46 people found this helpful

Compelling True Crime -portrait of a family

What about Kevin Pierce’s performance did you like?

His narration was excellent. He has a tone that sounds like the actor, Tom Hanks. At first I found the pace a bit slow, but then I settled into the story. Kevin got the right balance of conveying a serious story but without a dry historical distance. He used accents for the dialogue but these were done well and didn't detract from the subject.

Any additional comments?

This is the true story of a child disappearance and the investigation to solve the crime. It starts many years in the past with the story of Elaine (the mother) and then section two rewinds to tell the background of the father. Usually I dislike books that take ages to get to the event (in this case the disappearance of teenage Brenda), but I found this worked well in this book for two reasons. Firstly because the backstory was well told and in a personal way with dialogue rather than historical distance. Secondly it gave insight into the family so that when Brenda disappeared it was easier to empathise and understand the actions of the parents.After the story reaches the crime -the disappearance and aftermath it then goes back in time and we hear about the background of the main suspect. This provides an interesting viewpoint that many crime novels miss and it helps make the suspect a real person, rather than a caricature. I felt it didn't undermine the crime or excuse it, but put things into a wider context for the listener.I found the whole story compelling and I listened almost non-stop in my spare time, finishing in a few days. The fact I wasn't aware of the outcome helped keep this a 'page turner' for me. Finally, I must mention I received a no-cost copy in exchange for a review, but don't let this influence you. This really is a great listen that I wholeheartedly recommend. It's a portrait of life and family, poverty and tragedy-not a gruesome crime /CSI novel.

29 people found this helpful

Lots of Kevin Pierce...can't go wrong.

What did you love best about Salt of the Earth?

The narration was great and I loved the book. I really got into each of the characters and I felt that I understood all of the perspectives.

What was the most compelling aspect of this narrative?

The thing I liked about this one is that it went on for a long time and really developed the storyline without getting boring or mundane.

Have you listened to any of Kevin Pierce’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

I have begun to select books just because of Kevin Pierce. He is a perfect choice for this kind of book.

9 people found this helpful

A masterpiece

I've been completely immersed in this book in the two or three days it took me to listen to it.
Jack Olsen and Kevin Pierce come together to present a story I couldn't put down and despite having read dozens of his books and other true crime stories this one brought me to tears.

8 people found this helpful

Unusual Presentation Makes You Invested

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

I would recommend this book to any True Crime enthusiast. It's an unusual presentation, partly because the family history is so difficult and there's a tremendous backstory to involve the listener with the victims. You get a deeper sense of loss as the family experiences it.

Who was your favorite character and why?

I would say the mother is one of the strongest people I've heard of. She undergoes such trying and difficult times even before the true tragedy strikes.

Have you listened to any of Kevin Pierce’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

I've listened to many of his performances and this one is on par with his other books.

If you could give Salt of the Earth a new subtitle, what would it be?

Listen to Your Warning Signals

Any additional comments?

The construction of this book, as the forward states, is unusual for a True Crime. In and of itself, the approach is worthy of note, and it is uniquely appropriate for this story. It demonstrates Olsen's skill with writing a story based on how it is best written than simply adopting stories to a style.

8 people found this helpful

Literally the best book I have ever read/ listened

Would you listen to Salt of the Earth again? Why?

Yes, the development of characters is like nothing I have ever read before. You feel like you are right there experiencing the story with them.

What other book might you compare Salt of the Earth to and why?

I am currently reading another Jack Olsen book, and it is great, but this one is still the best.

Have you listened to any of Kevin Pierce’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

yes, many of them, he is by far the best narrator of all books I have listened to.

What’s the most interesting tidbit you’ve picked up from this book?

I don't want to spoil anything by talking details, but the strength of all of the characters was so inspiring, and I love the back story of all of the families.

Any additional comments?

If you don't get around to reading/ listening to any other books this year, make time for this one, it will be worth it. I am a rather harsh reviewer and many things can turn me off about books, and I have nothing at all but compliments to say about this book.

7 people found this helpful

Not One of His Best

Kevin Pierce does his usual good job reading this book.

The book itself is far too long for a crime of this nature. Olsen takes chapter on chapter to develop a picture of the family life and multiple troubles of the Gere family. It’s interesting, but the family members are not that easy to empathize with, particularly not Brenda’s father, Joe.

The murderer is identified quite early in the story, so there’s little suspense.

The rest is just a long, spun out tale. Too long in my opinion.The book could have been half the size. Frustrating because most of Olsen’s books are so good.

I saw that one reviewer had called this “two dimensional” true crime. That seems apt because there’s very little nuance or mystery.

5 people found this helpful

Kevin Pierce and Jack Olsen, need I say more?

This is a weaker turn for Jack Olsen, but that isn't much of a knock, by true crime standards in general I'd probably give this five stars, but for Jack it's only four. This combination of author and narrator is, or at least should be, legendary. Kevin Pierce is the best narrator of the serious and haunting, and you won't be let down.

5 people found this helpful

Great story, slow start

I would recommend this book to lovers of true crime novels, with the caveat that the first 2-plus hours are dedicated to describing the upbringing and town life of the parents in the story. The author takes you through their childhoods, albeit briefly, through meeting, dating, and having children...and then raising them until the daughter is 12 and is abducted. So I felt like it was more of a life story than a crime story. However, this is not a negative thing. I struggled to get through the first two and a half hours, wondering where the crime was. But if you can get through that, the writing starts to feel more relevant to the actual crime as the descriptions of family life detail the family dynamics and Brenda's (the daughters), role in the family, so you can imagine how her disappearance will affect each family member.
By the time it got to the abduction, I was hooked. I was even listening to the story during breaks at work, and feeling irritated I only had 15 minutes to devote to it.
Kevin Pierce narrates superbly and has a voice that, quite honestly, lends itself to hours of enjoyable listening.
I do recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in true crime, but again, it took patience for me to make it through the first 2.5 hours.

I received this book at no cost in exchange for a fair and honest review.

15 people found this helpful

LOVED IT

Loved how the writer told the story of love, strength, and pain. Really digs at your core.

4 people found this helpful