A good solid voyage of discovery

If you like historical non-fiction about interesting expeditions, this should be a good listen (I read the paper version). Lt. Wilkes is a classic flawed leader, aloof, somewhat cruel, but his determination drove his crew on a great voyage though he struggled for notoriety. The amazing collection of artifacts that Wilkes brought home formed the foundation of the Smithsonian collection. I really like the detail of maritime life circa 1840, and Philbrick delivers. His writing makes even provisioning ships interesting. His previous book "Heart of the Sea" was a bit more gripping (albeit more harsh), but "Sea of Glory" is a very good book by a great historical writer.

23 people found this helpful

Something’s Just not Speaking to me…

The Good – I am amazed that I never had heard of the ExEx before this book. Very disappointed in our public education system for that. From a purely historic point of view I liked the book. I liked learning about the expedition because I needed to learn about something so monumental. I made a few book marks for reference that I can return to later, but overall the book just didn’t give me what I had expected.

The Not So Good – To be fair I’m going to have to give this book a second listen, but on first pass it just lacks something. The book told a lot of the human stories, but didn’t tell much of the science stories at least not in much detail. The author went through great pains to explain in telling detail why a certain officer did a certain thing, but he didn’t go into much story telling about the science discoveries. This really didn’t strike me until the end of the book where he listed the hundreds of samples the expedition brought back with them. It left me saying; “why didn’t you tell more about those samples and how and where they came from?" I'm not sure if I should follow that question with an "ugh!" or a "duh!"?

The Narration - Scott Brick is one of my favorite narrators, but for some reason I don’t think he was the right fit for this particular book’s writing style. Not that it was bad by any measure, but I think someone with a deeper voice and slower cadence could have made the book more interesting? Perhaps a Brit don't you know? Although I’m sure someone would take umbrage to that given the national pride of the subject matter.

The Overall – Sea of Glory is okay and was fairly good overall. I definitely learned something, which I always appreciate. I will listen to it again to see if I missed something that would push my rating a bit higher, but I'm not sure that will happen. In closing, I’m not disappointed by the book, but I’m not overjoyed by it either.

16 people found this helpful

Loved it.

What did you love best about Sea of Glory?

Where to start? This is a detailed story of an American exploratory expedition, begun in 1838, that few people seem to know of or care about. I found it fascinating. Personalities, politics, and the course of history have managed to obscure the story of Wilkes, leader of the expedition, and the accomplishments of his lengthy voyage and explorations. This story is also a historical soap opera that will enthrall anyone who loves tales of explorers, the risks they took, the discoveries they made, and the interpersonal clashes and comradeship formed along the way.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Certainly not Wilkes himself. He is the epitome of the type of person whom I detest: an obsessive, insecure, self-serving bully who abused his crews and who took credit for their discoveries. He makes the British Captain Bligh appear warm and cuddly by comparison. My favorite character was a junior officer, William Reynolds, who was everything admirable that Wilkes was not, and who subsequently bore the brunt of Wilkes's jealousy and abusive treatment.

Which scene was your favorite?

There are far too many memorable scenes in this book to allow me to choose just one. I suspect Sea of Glory will be an earlier than usual re-listen for me.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Same as above--too many for me to choose one. Perhaps my favorite moments were any in which Reynolds received promotion, recognition or approval. Conversely, I was thrilled at any reference to Wilkes being discomfited by censure or inadequate recognition.

Any additional comments?

Great book. Perfect narration by Scott Brick.

5 people found this helpful

Politics, tyranny, science and leadership at best!

What did you love best about Sea of Glory?

The reading (or listening) of historic events always amazes me, and Nathaniel Philbrick was again superb in his research (also seen on his "In the Heart of the Sea") and the story of almost 4 years of a little known fantastic expedition. On top of that, Scott Brick is able to put you on the scene. One said that when you come to hate (or admire) a character so much, the author has done a great job. That is the case with Charles Wilkes and why not to say, politicians of that area, who would undermine specialists and facts on behalf of their own interest (much like today...). The findings, maps and drawings produced by the Ex Ex must be amazing so I will stop by at the Smithsonian this Summer to see as much as it is available, in person.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Probably William Reynolds, for his well kept, unknown journal that has documented much of what really happened in that voyage, contrary to what was documented in the "well controlled by Wilkes" journals of other officers. A short note for Sydney...... a cool dog!!!!

Which character – as performed by Scott Brick – was your favorite?

No one specifically but I have to say that you don't get tired of listening Scott Brick. He is VERY good for such adventures.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Yes, if I could. It is truly a captivating true story that raises the bar as far as what to read next....

Any additional comments?

Interesting to know the story of how the Poinsettia flower ended up in the United States and it got its name (don't Google, read the book...).

5 people found this helpful

almost as good the second time

What made the experience of listening to Sea of Glory the most enjoyable?

very good narration gave meaning to the words

Would you recommend Sea of Glory to your friends? Why or why not?

yes as Nathaniel Philbrick is one of my favorite history authors writing style is superb. This topic is probably his least known and that simply shouldn't be given the enormous contributions of the US Ex Ex.

Which scene was your favorite?

Exploration of Antarctica

Any additional comments?

I had read the printed version of the book when it was new so this was a really good comparison for me. the audiobook was tougher to follow but that's usually true as compared to having the pages in your hand.

5 people found this helpful

Very interesting book!

I really enjoyed this title. Some may find the level of detail of the voyage and what occurred daunting, but to me it was just right.

It's hard to say just how the author does it (good writing perhaps..), but somehow you feel swept away as if you were part of the expedition. Some of the passages were so captivating that I feel like I have actual memories of the events as if I were there at the time.

If you want to know about this fascinating chapter of history that remains surprisingly obscure, you will enjoy this audio book.

7 people found this helpful

Great Story, Terrible editing.

An amazing story almost ruined by awful, awful editing. If it wasnt for Scott Bricks top-notch narration and this book being from a great author, I would’ve returned this book. Sentences cut off in the middle, constant changes in audio quality, whole paragraphs missing... Overall it’s worth a listen to learn about the incredible journey these men undertook, but be prepared for a bumpy ride.

1 person found this helpful

Exceptional read!

A captivating tale brilliantly reconstructed and expertly narrated. The amount of research needed to put this story together is a truly monumental task. Well worth the read. I could not put it down.

1 person found this helpful

Good History

This is a good account of a very obscure bit of American history. Well read and interesting.

3 people found this helpful

Hoe Does Philbrick Do It!?!?!?

Masterful teleportation of a reader to the world of the 1840's up to the Civil War. The historical context of the books topic and events are skillfully woven into the reader's psyche. I knew not of this story beforehand but I appreciated being supportive ly transported to America during that time. And then there are the richness and multi-faceted representation of the characters...I felt like I could identify with them as contemporary, recognizable people.