Ok but definitely could put it down.

Story seemed labored and pedantic at times. After such a loooong read, the ending was disappointing and too obvious set up for sequel. Though talented writer, Mr Iles has succumbed to the money go-round.

19 people found this helpful

Depressing and frustrating

Greg Iles writes an excellent, attention holding story, but this series has become so depressing it makes me consider not reading any more of them. Tragedy abounds and the characters who should know better keep doing incredibly stupid, careless things which cause even more grief. The main character, Penn comes across as petulant and childish in this book when he has been imminently sensible and capable before. Considering the subject matter, I suppose the characters can't possibly win this one, but I found the book sad and frustrating, even though well written and the narration excellent. Not an experience I am anxious to repeat.

25 people found this helpful

Could have been half as long and twice as good

The idea of the story was great.
I've loved the other books in the series- but this one seemed like he was getting paid per page.

It did serve nicely to listen to on the airplane, though. If I fell asleep for an hour, I didn't miss much.

20 people found this helpful

Narrator a problem

After listening to the first four Penn Cage books so brilliantly narrated by Dick Hill, I was beside myself with disappointment and grief that Natchez Burning was NOT narrated by the incomparable Mr. Hill. I protested in every way I could and truly hoped that Robert Petkoff would do a good job with The Bone Tree. But sadly, The residents of the deep south do not have southern accents in his voice and I find that very disturbing. I am going to return this audible version and buy the book in print. Then I can read it and imagine Dick Hill's voice and the mood and rhythm of the south that is totally lacking in Petkoff's narration.
Again, I feel abandoned as an audible consumer of this series. Very sad.

55 people found this helpful

Better as a book than audiobook

This was not my favorite of the Penn Cage novels. I’ve read one and listened to three. This one is darker than the others. But it’s major flaw is that parts of it are just downright boring. There is a lot of conspiracy theory discussion that just had my eyes glazing over. Sometimes these discussions went on for what seemed like an interminable length of time. In a written book I would have scanned past it but with an audio book that isn’t really possible. There is quite a lot of character development and a legitimate storyline. Overall, you probably need to read or listen to it if there are going to be more Penn Cage novels or you will miss some critical developments, but if you’re a reader and a listener as I am, put this one down in the to read column.

The narration was fine but was the third narrator of the three Penn Cage novels I’ve listened to. It would be nice if they would settle on one.

4 people found this helpful

Around 20 hours too long

And it ended with a lead to the next book. I needed to force myself to continue after the first 10 hours & it was a waste of time.

14 people found this helpful

A very long airport paperback

What disappointed you about The Bone Tree?

Although the plot is quite interesting, weaving racist violence in Mississippi with hypotheses about the Kennedy assassination (sometimes a bit improbable), the style is childish and repetitive. The characters are always feeling "chills on their spine" or "trembling knees" and shaking hands when faced with danger, which by the way is ALL the time. I'm disappointed in Iles, having read other good books by him.

Has The Bone Tree turned you off from other books in this genre?

Not in this genre but I'm turned off Iles.

What do you think the narrator could have done better?

Actually, the narrator does a very creditable job, with several voices, black and white, male and female.

If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from The Bone Tree?

There are many scenes that could disappear without affecting the novel, for example all the intimate soul searching scenes by the characters which turn out to be corny and lifeless. Some good surgery would actually improve it.

Any additional comments?

I think Iles bit off more than he could chew with this one.

22 people found this helpful

A big let down

I was so disappointed with this story. "Surely, crap happens, but golly jee whiz, does any one in the story get a break! The death of who I believe is the heroine was so anti- climactic that could not believe that she was really dead. I demand a re-write. Let's back up and change the story from that point. It would feel so much better.

21 people found this helpful

A book that wants to be a movie

I began this novel with an outward groan, not just in contemplation of the 816 pgs. (32 1/2 hrs. audio) facing me, but in reflection of part 1 of this trilogy, Natchez Burning. It was a brick of a book. It contained all the hallmarks of an entertaining read, but was weighed down with detail so burdensome I couldn't get momentum. The 32 hrs. felt like reading real-time. With that premise: Just a few days ago (book-wise), Penn Cage and his fiancée Caitlin Masters, barely escaped with their lives after a gruesome torture session at the hands of a sadistic break-off cell of the KKK. Bone Tree picks up on Day 2 and from the get-go it's clear, TBT loses no time tossing the barely on their feet couple back into the grinder. Wisely, Iles lays down a refresher course for those of us that can't recall the who-what-where & why's to the 35 hr. prequel. It's quick, but thorough.

This is a marathon of action (and listening), literally stuffed to capacity with new secrets that seem to begat more secrets, widening the circle of conspirators, and dangers for Penn, his family and dwindling support team...and I only wished for an editor occasionally this time out. While better than Natchez Burning, the same issues that tormented me through NB still appear in the pages of TBT: glut. But it's Iles' book and if he wants to include the dalliances of sandwich making and downloading Google Maps between dodging snipers and ever lurking ne'er-do-wells, then so be it. (I'd still argue a savvy editor would do some hefty pruning.) Tracking all the people and past events demands attention; the trivialities came close to being distracting. Keeping up with the KKK, the FBI, JFK, RFK, MLK, Castro, Snake, and so on, is mental charting for Mensa members.

Somewhere in the surfeit of detail and double-crosses, the quest switches from solving the murder of Dr. Tom Cage's African-American nurse Viola Turner in Natchez, to digging into questions about conspiracies in the murders of JFK, RFK, MLK. It seems a giant leap away from the South to Castro, but Iles says the trilogy is completed, which I interpret to mean he knows where it's all going. Book 2 avoids the *middle novel* doldrums with new revelations and unexpected twists, but it does continue that tradition of the hanging non-conclusion. Be warned that if you enter here, you're committed to the 3rd book. (If nothing else, you're so going to want to see how & if Snake gets what's coming to him.) Kennedy conspiracies seem overplayed, but I admit I'm curious to see how Iles answers his own questions; how he combines the facts that are his framework with his fictional story.

After the disappointment of NB, I didn't think I would continue with the trilogy. Two things changed my mind (and my son-in-law who's reading this with me):
- First of all, I didn't care for the narrator of NB, a choice that affected my experience of the book. But, I noticed that people who read, rather than listened to, the book, overwhelmingly liked it. Optimistically, I counted on a change of narrators to improve the *Penn Cage* experience. Petkoff is a talented, accomplished actor/narrator. He is expressive, energetic, and noteworthy...better than NB, but again, not how I hear Penn Cage. Why Dick Hill isn't narrating this trilogy...? I wondered if he was still working, and Google says he is. I miss the quality of voice he brought to Penn -- that laid back Southern Comfort that embodied the characters, the history and the place. Hoping for a better suited narrator with TBT turned out to be wishful thinking.
- Secondly, NB and TBT are both novels that border on the farcical, considering the characters, the collusion, complexity, conspiracy, and the nine lives of the all the players...at least I thought so, until I read about the very real journalist Stanley Nelson, the editor of The Concordia Sentinel, and Pulitzer Prize finalist. Nelson is fictionally portrayed by Iles as journalist Henry Sexton, and it's his journalistic work researching the '64 real-life killing of Frank Morris (depicted in NB as musician Albert Norris) by a KKK terrorist cell known as the Silver Dollar Group (depicted in NB as the Double Eagles) that inspired Iles' Natchez Burning. Unless Iles has painted himself into a corner, this can only have one heck of a conclusion.

For me, this book was the better book; the history added depth to the characters and their philosophies, and the story began to have direction and substance beyond just sensational violence. With the roots of the story embedded in history the book became more significant. "Truth is sometimes stranger than fiction..." to quote another Southerner.

While I was hesitant about part 2, I'm anxious for the conclusion. Then there's that issue of the narration.........
*[Natchez Burning is to become a cable series with Sony and Amazon Studios, produced by Tobey Maguire and David Hudgins]

37 people found this helpful

just a drop dead great book

What did you love best about The Bone Tree?

the complexity of the story and how it was handled

Who was your favorite character and why?

the father ... wise and experienced

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

can't do int because of the wonderful length

Any additional comments?

I am normally not a fan of this author but this is just to great a book not to say good things about.

3 people found this helpful