Better than I expected! Close to a 5 🌟

After reading some of the less flattering reviews I wasn't sure what I would get- but it was much better than the reviews led me to expect. I thought Maeve was a great new character and I've already purchased the next book in the series. some people criticized the narrator and that baffles me as well - I thought the narrator did a great job and I had no trouble following different characters. Though I'm often not a fan of switching points of view in this book I thought it worked well. I'm tempted to give it 5 stars just to raise the overall average. if there was something in between 4 and 5 star rating that's where I would put it. Couldn't stop listening. A great find in my opinion!

45 people found this helpful

Disappointing

What aspect of Sarah Coomes’s performance would you have changed?

It must really be a challenge to distinguish so many English accents as well as the different ages and characters of everyone in this book. Coombes makes a brave job of it, but some character's voices sound cartoonish, sometimes it's hard to tell who's speaking in a conversation where both voices sound quite similar. There are also times when the character is thinking the words, but it's hard to understand that except in retrospect.

Did The Burning inspire you to do anything?

This is a ridiculous question.

Any additional comments?

There are some interesting characters and events, and I did listen all the way through. The romantic relationships are incompletely drawn. A couple of characters (no spoilers here- don't worry) do not seem consistent--their personalities seem to shift to fit the needs of the plot. I was disappointed in the book as a whole. To me, it seems that the murderer is transparently easy to guess very early on. The last hour or so is eye-rollingly trite and tedious. The combination of an over-long letter and some supposed newspaper accounts try to do what should have been accomplished in the main part of the book.

11 people found this helpful

Glad I listened to this one last

I'm really glad that I listened to this book in the Maeve Kerrigan series last because had I listened to it first, I don't think I would have listened to the other books in this series, which are VERY good.

I found Louise to be very annoying in this book and the last hour of the book which is mostly a letter from Louise simply needed to finish!

I don't think this book is critical to Maeve Kerrigan series if you are interested in reading or listening to these books. All of the other books in the series are much better and maybe that is because of the interaction of Josh Derwent. He's a bugger and I love him! He adds to the story.

31 people found this helpful

Engrossing: well-written and well-read

I really enjoyed this book; it was predictable in terms of the culprit, but the structure of the book with changing narrators worked well in creating a suspenseful denouement and strong character creation. The narrator is excellent. Can't wait for the next in the series!

9 people found this helpful

What is Better than Book 1 in a Series You Like ??

Jane Casey has done something difficult. . .successfully created a character who follows in the footsteps of Jane Tennison (Prime Suspect) and Anna Travis while establishing her own identity. The plots are clever, the dialogue smart and the narration superb. If you enjoy British police procedurals this is a wonderful series !

25 people found this helpful

Thorough story- full of mystery

I really liked this book & the way the author presented the plot. it was chucked full of psychological suspense & it kept my interest throughout. it had plenty of winding police involvement & i liked the way the characters were kept straight in the presentation in this book. Now on to the next Casey book. Satisfied reader

6 people found this helpful

Predictable Plot, Annoying Narrator

This is not one of the better detective stories I have listened to recently. The plot is fairly predictable, nothing very interesting. It's a standard whodunnit. I do not like the deliberately misleading introduction of Louise (if you listen to/read it, you'll understand what I mean). It's immature and lacks imagination on the writer's part. There is nothing here that makes me want to continue listening if this should become a series.

What I enjoyed least about this book is the narrator. The chair she is sitting in often creaks noticeably in the background. She has a bad habit of sucking in air between her teeth. Sometimes it could be appropriate to the dialogue, but at other times it's just annoying. Her portrayal of male characters is very distracting as her voice becomes extremely harsh-sounding and nasal. Right around the beginning of the second half it is obvious that she has a rather bad head cold and at times her voice becomes so scratchy that it I found myself actually clearing MY throat! I wanted to yell at her to take a drink of water! When this happens, I don't understand why they don't just stop recording and wait a few days for the reader to get better instead of pushing them until they are hoarse. Things like this are distracting to me and really detract from the listening experience. A narrator should be unobtrusive, in my opinion.

I wish I had saved the credit, but it isn't the worst I've listened to. It's just....meh. Save your credit unless you're desperate for Britcrime and have listened to everything else.

31 people found this helpful

I look forward to more

This was a surprise. It was better than I expected but left a bit to be desired. The denouement(s) were predictable and rushed, in my opinion. On the other hand, I liked Maeve. I can see her developing in her job. I wonder, though, why she almost always went alone when interviewing people.

The narration was acceptable. I look forward to reading/listening to more.

3 people found this helpful

A psychological character-study

Any additional comments?

If you are looking for a fast-paced slasher mystery, this isn't it. Still, I enjoyed this book so much more than I expected. It's easy to guess who-dunnit, but that doesn't matter, or hurt the story one bit. What made this book unusual was, it felt more like a psychological character-study than a police procedural murder mystery.The story is told through alternating chapters, narrated by the detective and the victim's best friend, Louise, who is used to give an insight into the victim's life. What emerges are some fairly insightful examinations into three contrasting characters. I was hooked by these women- their lives, their struggles, their motives, their secrets, etc.. When spun together they weave a compelling story.

3 people found this helpful

For mystery lovers! You'll love this series!

I listen to 2-3 audiobooks a week (I have over 2000) , so it's especially great when I find a new author and series that I love. This is one of those, that I can't put down, and holds my attention throughout, and I'm wanting to listen to book after book in the serise.

3 people found this helpful