Moving, Heartbreaking, Quality Writing.

Any additional comments?

The subject matter- life in a post-war TB sanatorium - may not sound like thrilling material for a historical novel; but in the hands of prize-winning novelist,Linda Grant, the mundane becomes intriguing and rewarding listening.

The lives of several TB patients become intertwined as they 'learn to be patients' and to wait for a new miracle cure for TB, desperately hoping that they will be chosen for the experimental treatment. The lives of these people are all tragic in different ways and as the story progresses they face up to their illness in a variety of ways. There are happy and sad endings, personal triumphs and failures and the formation of relationships between class and cultural divides.

Set against the early days of television and the NHS this is a story of morality, illness, broken promises, love and the lifelong effects of guilt.

The narration was pretty average, hence the 4* rating, and the publisher's blurb went a bit over the top on this one - the all out rebellion of patients was more like a polite protest in my view.

But overall I really enjoyed the story and I learned a lot about the lives and fates of TB sufferers in the 1950s.

3 people found this helpful

Wooden

Wooden characters, unconvincing plot, and lifeless narration. I really wanted to like this book, and continued, hoping it would pick up ... should have given up long before the end.

2 people found this helpful

Wonderful story spoiled by very poor reading.

Many common words mispronounced and the wrong emphasis on words. The voice was right but why wasn't the recording checked or edited?

1 person found this helpful

Wonderful book marred by the reading

Did anyone listen to this before it was published? The reader’s mispronunciation of so many words, and oddly inappropriate stresses is unbelievable. Enthusiasm is not enough. Reading audiobooks (especially for those of us unable to read the book for ourselves) is a difficult art. The producer should at least have ensured a consistent (if wrong!) pronunciation of tuberculosis. Not to mention Edgbaston. Very disappointed.

1 person found this helpful

Poor Narration

I’ve read most of Linda Grant’s books and enjoyed them all but this audiobook is completely marred by the very poor narration. The pronunciation is the worst I’ve ever heard and I was laughing out loud at some of it: antimacassars and Gaggia for example. This reader should not be allowed near any further books, sorry to say!

1 person found this helpful

tuberculosis treatment in a sanatorium

If you could sum up The Dark Circle in three words, what would they be?

informing, mulit-layered, deft

What did you like best about this story?

The way the characters develop and change through the story. The breakdown of class and stigma for the residents of the sanatorium.
The writing - it is accessible but literary and touching.

What about Daniel Coonan’s performance did you like?

I found Daniel Coonan's narration excellent. He pitched the characters very well and I would look out for his 'performances' again.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

No - too long but also too full of information and like a rich dessert - it needs savouring!

Any additional comments?

This is worth a read/listen - unusual subject matter, well-written and well-read. It is not a pacy thriller but is more meaty and satisfying than a 'beach read' type book.

1 person found this helpful

I got bored

I liked the beginning, the Jewishness and learning about tuberculosis in the post war years. But somehow I just lost interest... didn't see the point of the cruise part....and then felt irritated with it all

Very enjoyable

I really enjoyed this audio book, the narrator is very clear and had the right sort of voice for Kenny and Miriam.
My Mother and Father each had a sister with TB, one recovered and one died. So I was interested to hear about the running of a Sanitorium.
The main characters were very well brought to life.

Fascinating

First I've heard or read from this author. I'll definitely try more. Fascinating characters and feel of the time.

2 people found this helpful