I've loved 35 books by Cornwell: this one -- no

It's hard when your favorite author puts out a book which is just simply so tedious you can't finish. I believe Cornwell is nothing short of a genius so I cannot imagine why he chose to use as a story line a particularly unimportant piece of history and then have no character driven drama aound it.

I'm mystified,

30 people found this helpful

Disappointing

I am a huge Cornwell fan. I have read every book he's written and the Sharpe's books at least twice. The man can make soap bubbles sound exciting; but not this time. The numerous characters took a long time to develop and then the lead characters didn't do very much in the book. He created some likeable characters but didn't really test them or put them under the gun. I love history so I didn't mind the trivial side notes and the historical detail but this info didn't add much to the story. Usually Cornwell takes the historical detail and weaves it into the story in a way that allows the reader to "feel" the history and it is done so artfully that it enhances the story and puts the reader in the middle of the action. Instead this book felt disjointed and the characters and events somewhat random and disconnected. Sometimes the side notes were interesting, like the dialogue where the militia has to eat crow and request help from the continental regulars but there was no follow up in the story where this information comes back as part of the story. I wanted to know what happened and how the event affected the outcome but the author never explained. The book takes a long time to break into action and the tone of the book at first seems rather light and the characters somewhat comical, then boom the battle starts and body parts start flying. I was somewhat startled by the transition. One of the things that I enjoy from this author is the anticipation of the action. Usually as the characters are developed in a Cornwell book they are placed in increasingly tense situations and conflict until the whole story starts to race downhill. By the time the reader is thrust into the battle sequences the story is at a full gallop and the reader is right in the middle of the action. Not this time. The reader was also very weak. I will pretend that Cornwell's evil twin wrote this one and will wait with unbridled anticipation for the next Cornwell novel.

16 people found this helpful

Good but not Great

I've listened to several Cornwell books on Audible. Usually they're compelling, tense and with superb narration. While this one held my interest, the tension was a little forced, the narrator simply "acceptable" and the audio quality suspect in places (at least places other than a school gymnasium).

I'm not clear on why the characters are a little more shallow than the typical Cornwell - perhaps he's trying to stick closer to the written record of the Penobscot expidition. I'd have to add that I really appreciate the "Author's Notes" Cornwell includes at the end of his novels, wherein he expands somewhat on the historical context and his departures for the purposes of narrative. That was sadly absent in this edition.

10 people found this helpful

Can't get through it

simply put, it has been two months of trying and I can not get through this book. Dull, tedious and in need of better narration.
sad because I have listened to every book Bernard Cornwell has available an purchased without thought, or reading review and this time I must say, don't spend the credit.

16 people found this helpful

Interesting Story, Horrible Narration

I did find the story interesting but it was almost impossible to listen to this one. Perhaps the narrator could work on other tales adequately, but I will remember his name and question whether to listen to other books he's involved with.

9 people found this helpful

Cornwell's worst book

What would have made The Fort better?

An ending.

What does Robin Bowerman bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Outstanding reading - really brought many different characters to life.

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

Disappointment - Cornwell is one of the best authors ever, but this is clearly his worst book. A rambling story without an ending. Unlike all his other books.

Any additional comments?

Skip the Fort and listen to the Richard Sharpe series instead.

2 people found this helpful

Disappointing

Not Cornwell's usual. One of my favorite authors and I can't following the story line if there is one.
Think twice before listening to this one.

2 people found this helpful

Not for the faint of heart

I don't know of any other author that could have done justice to this bit of American history. It has a lot of charaters... and ships... to keep track of and the narrator does a great job helping to keep them sorted out. The story itself is just plain frustrating and leaves the reader wondering how America ever made it past the Revolutionary War. All that said, it was well worth the credit and time. What an interesting and little known part of our history!

2 people found this helpful

Disapointing story... boring

Struggled to get through this book. I enjoy BC’s books a lot, so I might have expected too much. Boring most of the time....

1 person found this helpful

A tough loss for the Americans

As an American, I don't get much opportunity to read about the American Revolution from the viewpoint of Britain. A very interesting perspective that I wouldn't mind reading more of. Admittedly, it's hard hearing about the shortfalls of American Patriots like Paul Revere and the ineptitude of some American forces during that time. But it also makes a lot of sense when you take the time period and political environment.

1 person found this helpful