Performance takes a bit of getting used to

This was a wonderful book, so complex and heartfelt. The comparisons to "To Kill a Mockingbird" are apt in that a young boy learns about his life and his family through experiencing a crime. His father is a judge on a Native American reservation.

Well deserving of the National Book Award.

The reader is a Native American actor, I think, which is great, because he speaks with a cadence that is distinctly from that cultural background. The reason it takes getting used to is that this sort of cadence puts emphases on other parts of the sentence than we are used to hearing from other actors who read audiobooks. It was odd at first, but after getting used to the style, I really enjoyed his performance and I think it added a needed authenticity.

50 people found this helpful

MADE THE LISTS OF BEST BOOKS!

I purchased this novel because I saw the title on quite a few lists of the best books of 2012 and I wasn't disappointed in the least. It's a coming-of-age story at the centre of First Nation history, reservation life, Indian mythology, family, a horrendous crime and so much more. Wonderful, a 'do not miss' novel. I had some trouble with the narrator at first but became accustomed to his style. I could have listened to hours more.

81 people found this helpful

Vignettes of Brilliance

Where does The Round House rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

Difficult to say -- This is a long string of vignettes, many of which are brilliant and made better by the excellent narrator. I listen during commuting and as such, didn't feel that the story was done justice by my split attention between driving and listening. This is a book better listened to with full attention. There are too many subtle gems to miss.

What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?

The interplay between native American assimilation and independence -- always in tension and a contrast that was always illuminating.

What does Gary Farmer bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Cadence, tone, and intonation. This was a story made to be read by Farmer.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

It made me feel. It was raw and beautiful.

Any additional comments?

As I mentioned, this is a book to listened to as narrated by Farmer. Wouldn't have been nearly as special to have read this book. Just don't listen while distracted. Do yourself a favor and listen with intention.

75 people found this helpful

Heavy in My Heart

This book has been heavy in my head. Had I written a knee-jerk review 3 days ago from that thick head, I would have misinformed you. I hadn't synthesized the weight of all that is between the words: the legend and mythology that give eloquence to the silly ramblings of an old sleeping man; the traditions that guided the daily activities of the Native American characters; the history of duplicity that corralled a people into reservations and snuffed out their cultural identity. Heavy in my head because this book is structured so beautifully that much of it speaks to us from the spaces between the words--a language we grasp in our core consciousness. Now translated...the story is heavy in my heart.

The *Heads I win, Tails you lose* treaties that made a story like this possible, (virtually creating a Free Rape Zone) are in the words of this story's narrator, "a gut kick," that compounds an already tragic event. The characters are vividly written and fondly familiar as a family member or good neighbor. Especially compelling is the young Joe. (The story is recalled by an older Joe.) The violent hate crime perpetrated against his mother skins him of his innocence and naivete, catapulting him prematurely into a foreign adult world. His group of friends, their teenage rites of passages and proclivities, tentatively anchor him to his youthful life, and reminded me of the group of friends in Stand By Me (The Body).

There are many themes in this intricate and tense novel, some rooted generations deep. (Reading Native American literature sometimes makes me feel like a person with the same surname as a horrendous criminal must feel each time the name is broadcast.) Erdrich writing is stunning - almost painfully beautiful as she combines the contrasting elements that make up this profound story. I would say more profound, because of her craftsmanship, than *depresssing*...one of the words in reviews that kept me from listening before...

I have considered this book since it was published and passed for different reasons. The asides, or the stories told by the elders of the tribes, may seem like irrelevant ramblings, humorous or raunchy stories. Look passed the old Mooshum's dream-talking, and the aunts and grandmothers intent on embarassing the young boys with their youthful recollections--these stories are crucial to the heart of this story--they are the history, the scripture, the culture ties, the logic, and cleverly placed by Erdrich to keep the suspense in the forefront while adding perspective. Addressing the narrator: Gary Farmer is a Native American that has many acting credits and obviously has experience with script. His reading hit me as authentic rather than disruptive and added a necessary discomfort to the rhythm of words--because they should be a little uncomfortable in this context, and the story should sit heavy in our hearts.

I read that this novel is the middle of a trilogy (the first volume being Plague of Doves). I love finding an author that is new to me and I can't wait to read everything Erdrich has written. Very deserving of the the National Book Award.

139 people found this helpful

Louise Erdrich hits one out of the park

For me, this novel was about as close to perfect as contemporary fiction gets. It's beautifully written, well-voiced, full of memorable characters, and a rich snapshot of life on a North Dakota Indian reservation in the late 1980s. The narrator, Joe, is a grown man remembering a few life-shaping months of his early teens. The book begins with Joe and his father, a reservation judge, coming upon Joe's mother, who has just been assaulted and raped. The situation soon grows in complexity -- Geraldine takes to her bed and can't (or won't) recall who attacked her, and because the attack occurred somewhere close to the reservation boundary, it's unclear whose legal jurisdiction it falls into.

With his mother in legal and emotional limbo, and the police seemingly disinterested, the young Joe takes it on himself to solve the crime, though he proceeds in a typically fumbling, distractible adolescent manner. What follows is a story that's a lot of things at once. It's a mystery, a coming-of-age story, a drama of family and best friends, and a reflection on the history of a people struggling to maintain control of their own laws and culture within the larger framework of American society and its systems. Through Joe's young eyes, we come to grasp the weight of a complex past on the present day. I was in awe of the subtle purity with which Erdrich makes these separate pieces connect, ultimately bringing her protagonist towards terms with his reality and his identity.

As I said, the characters are wonderful. There's Joe's soft-spoken, intelligent father, Bazil. There's Joe's best friend, Cappy, the boy we all remember from adolescence who seemed to be a step ahead of us in confidence and experience, if not always wisdom. There's an ex-Marine priest, who has a singularly painful reason for choosing his vocation. There's an old man whose nocturnal tales confuse (or perhaps not) real events and tribal mythology. There's one of the dirtiest-minded old grandmas I've ever encountered in fiction. Erdrich's craft as a writer is such that I felt that I knew these people well and could picture their backstories and relationships within a couple pages of meeting them. (If I have a complaint at all, it's that the villain's pretty one-dimensional, but that wasn’t a big issue for me.)

The central, recurring theme in The Round House is that of overlapping worlds. I knew I was in love with the writing a few chapters in, when Joe explains Star Trek: the Next Generation from the perspective of reservation boys. In this personal way, Erdrich explores several other blurred boundaries, such as that between the Indian world and the white world, the way both Christian and native beliefs have personal meaning, the difficult crossing between childhood and the adult world, and the conflict between personal justice and the importance of rational, impartial law. I loved the way she brought these separate threads together in the raw, but beautifully symbolic final chapters. This is the novel that many aspiring writers attend MFA programs in search of, but few pull off.

To me, Gary Farmer did a good job with the audiobook narration, though some listeners might find the halting intonation of his Native American accent a little reminiscent of William Shatner. The only other book of Erdrich's I've read before was A Plague of Doves; while it was good, this is the one to start with.

28 people found this helpful

local Erdrich fan

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

yes, but only if you have read some other works by Louise Erdrich there are characters that pepper this novel from some of her earlier works that make it delightful to hear them mentioned again.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Linda - she just had a mystery about her.

What does Gary Farmer bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

His voice but I felt his accent was spot on...and brought real life to the male characters especially.

If you could take any character from The Round House out to dinner, who would it be and why?

That's tough probably "ooops" I just loved him!

5 people found this helpful

An amazing story by a compelling storyteller

Don't give up on the narrator--the story itself is well worth listening to, and the narration improves slowly as the story builds, especially in the second half. I found the book to be excellent, the storyline exciting and fascinating, and the characters well-drawn. The story is told through the eyes of a 13-year-old native American boy, which is quite a feat for a 58-year-old woman writer, and she pulls it off beautifully. The narrator is apparently an American Indian actor, but he is so unskilled at narrating that I almost gave up on the book at first. He does the strangest things with sentences, often coming full-stop after the verb, and seeming to start a new sentence (as in, "He laid his bike against the fence. Before he went into the woods.") His inflection is all over the map, oftentimes obscuring the meaning of the words he's reading. (Didn't he practice ahead of time, one wonders?) As the story builds in intensity, however, the narrator seems to fall into a more normal inflection pattern, and contributes to the excitement of the story instead of detracting from it, as he does in the first half of the book. In any case, the story is so compelling that I stuck with it, and was so glad I did...even gasping and weeping a few times. Thank you, Louise Erdrich.

35 people found this helpful

“The sentence was to endure”

Louise Erdrich's The Round House is narrated by Joe (nicknamed Oops because he was his parents’ accident) Coutts, who many years later as a married lawyer (?) is recalling the summer of 1988 when he had just turned thirteen. Joe and his family were members of the Ojibwe (Anishinabe) tribe living then on the Ojibwe reservation in North Dakota. Joe’s father Bazil was a judge, his mother Geraldine a tribal enrollment specialist. The novel opens with Joe and father finding Geraldine covered in blood and vomit and smelling like gasoline. She has been raped and nearly immolated. But because she won’t reveal who did it or why, Joe takes it upon himself to find the perpetrator so as to bring him to justice of one kind or another. Joe has suspects, for instance a white man from a slimy family involved in one of his father’s court cases or the new white Catholic priest who’s a scarred veteran proficient at shooting gophers. Meanwhile, his mother becomes spider-like in her emaciation and isolates herself from her family.

Despite, or perhaps because of, the appalling nature of the brutal rape and its tragic effects on Joe’s mother and his family, the novel is often very funny, Erdrich writing comical and quirky scenes, details, and asides through Joe’s narratorial voice, giving him and the reader plenty of chuckling or smiling release valves to ease sympathy and outrage. There are eccentric characters, like Joe’s grandfather Mooshum and Linda Lark. There are things like the account of the Star Trek Next Generation characters liked (Worf, Data, Deanna Troi) and disliked (Riker, Wesley) by Joe and his friends; the time when a self-important medicine man in training unwittingly dumped a lot of hot pepper herbs on the heated stones in a sweat lodge; the description of his friends’ idiosyncratic bicycles; his thirteen-year-old crush on his ex-stripper aunt’s breasts. Lines like, “There are Indian grandmas who get too much church and Indian grandmas where the church doesn’t take and who are let loose in their old age to shock the young.” Even when he and his friends are scouring the woods around the Round House (an abandoned symbolically female site for traditional rituals) for clues that his mother’s attacker might have left behind, an intensely serious activity, Joe makes us smile via a legion of hungry ticks and his friend’s comical story about being accidentally flea bombed inside his house when he was four.

There is a harrowing scene where Joe notices his mother’s vertebrae sticking out through her nightgown, her shoulder blades like knives, her complexion pasty, her eyes darkly circled, her hair lank and greasy, and her vitality dim, and then announces to her that he’ll find and burn her attacker, only to have her briefly assume her former mother persona’s authority to tell him that he will not cause her more fear, will not search for her attacker, and will not ask her questions, and then he tries to teach their wolf-dog Pearl how to fetch, only to have her intimidatingly refuse, closing her teeth on his wrist as if to snap his bones, leading Joe to say with humorous understatement, “So you don’t play fetch, I see that now.”

Erdrich has an eye and an ear for how adolescent boys talk, act, feel, think: the teasing, boasting, joking, supporting, and rough housing; the randy bawdy hungry reckless behavior. It all feels real and adds layers of comedy and pathos to the story. Joe and his buddies (Cappy, Angus, and Zach) speculate on whether it’s better to have a penis looking like Darth Vader or the evil hooded Emperor, get side-tracked when looking for evidence by the lucky find of a couple of cold sixpacks, make Indian jokes, tease each other, sneak cigarettes, are embarrassed by lewd remarks from grandmothers, and enjoy each other’s company. When Joe gets his friends to help him try to find and nail his mother’s attacker, the book almost gets a Stand by Me vibe (though less sentimental).

Throughout, Erdrich writes plenty of reservation life details about politics, policing, law, health care, enrollment, adoption, food, families, groceries, parties, powwows, sweat lodges, Catholicism, history, pronunciation of d instead of th, and more, as well as plenty of references to things like “the gut-kick of our history” experienced by all Native Americans by which, for instance, the USA (from the founding fathers and early Supreme Court on) eagerly took their land by any means devisable, or by which their people were lynched, or by which the federal government enacted outrageous laws interfering with their own legal systems and so on. Indeed, much of the book centers on the question of tribal autonomy (or lack thereof) when it comes to legal matters and criminal cases. “They’d built that place [The Round House] to keep their people together and to ask for mercy from the Creator, since justice was so sketchily applied on earth.”

In addition to Star Trek: The Next Generation, Erdrich also writes in plenty of vintage popular culture references to the likes of Lord of the Rings, Dune, Star Wars, Alien, and TV action games.

She does much vivid and witty writing, like “Sour turnips and tomatoes, beets and corn, scorched garlic, unknown meat, and an onion gone bad, the concoction gave off a penetrating reek,” or like he “labored with incremental ferocity. . . ant-like.”

The novel becomes bleak towards the end, shedding humor in favor of tragedy and loss and sudden aging, and I have to think more about what I think of the abrupt conclusion: is it perversely unfulfilling or bracingly honest? It is like the cold breath of a windigo winter wind: “We passed over in a sweep of sorrow that would persist into our small forever. We just kept going.” I am glad to have read the novel and do recommend it as a necessary book for anyone interested in historical and contemporary Native American life, but. . . I prefer Erdrich’s Love Medicine or Birchbark House books.

The audiobook reader Gary Farmer is just right.

3 people found this helpful

It was not my favorite

This book was beautifully written, but I was a little bored while listening. I felt detached from the characters and found my mind wandered quite often.

11 people found this helpful

The right voice for this Erdrich story

Would you listen to The Round House again? Why?

Yes. The voice grows on you, with its reservation pauses and pronunciations. The story spirals through time, with details in its diversions that will take more than one listen to catch.

What other book might you compare The Round House to and why?

Not a book, but a Joni Mitchell song--Cherokee Louise

Which character – as performed by Gary Farmer – was your favorite?

Mooshum

If you could take any character from The Round House out to dinner, who would it be and why?

Cappy, because he'd be good company and easy on the eye, from what I hear

11 people found this helpful