There is NOTHING wrong with this book

This sounds like lackluster praise. To the contrary, it is the best thing I can ever say about a book. You know how you read a book and you get aggravated by some little annoyance, or you feel something was left out or unexplained, or you start to feel differently towards the characters than you think you should? Or maybe you know how a turn of phrase or plot line can make you roll your eyes. All these things pull you from the story. It can still be a great book. You can still love it. But there are things wrong with it none the less. In my opinion, there is NOTHING wrong with this book. If there were any imperfections, it was so completely fantastically amazing that I didn't even notice. I was not pulled from the story once. I am still thinking about the characters now. It was all real. Funny, witty, heartbreaking. Let me repeat - funny (in case you missed it). Yes there is heartache and anguish. But there is humor and redemption, too. Just like life. This is my first Audible review. I liked it so much that I couldn't not rate it.

153 people found this helpful

✫✫ 4 Stars ✫✫

This is my 2nd time listening to this audio and when I started I only remembered that I really liked it the first time so this was like listening for the first time all over again and this time I loved it even more.
This book was powerful in that of healing, loving and moving forward! I really liked how different all the characters were from each other and especially the way the relationship between Josh & Nastya began and formed without even conversations. They just seemed to get each other from the beginning and that melted my heart. It was like they were magnets and were drawn to each other. This book had a lot of great side characters that help make it as great as it was! I would love a book for Drew and seeing him grow! I also loved the explanation of the name of this book too!

The narration was perfect. I love both these narrators and this is exactly how this book needed to sound!

14 people found this helpful

Engrossing and well-done angsty teen novel!

There are teen novels and then again, there are teen novels. Some I find merely geared to teenage girls and others appeal to a wide variety of ages, like this one. This book held me captive for two days. I felt like an interloper in an intense relationship and I just had to know how it turned out.

We have two very emotionally damaged teens who meet in their last year of high school. They are attracted to each other even before they even realize it. However, their life histories prevent them from acknowledging their real feelings toward one another. Their individual histories are so devastating that they may not even be able to experience or recognize true feelings. This is the story of their relationship with each other and also with their friends. It has mature subject material and would most likely not be appropriate for younger teens.

I found the characters in this story to be well-developed, interesting, and believable. I found the ending to be very well done . The narrators are both excellent. They are extremely convincing--it felt like they were the actual characters they were "playing." If you like YA literature and emotionally intense novels, The Sea of Tranquility is for you!

39 people found this helpful

Totally Engaging

Any additional comments?

The character development was excellent...Nastya and Josh are captivating young people. Even secondary characters, e.g., Drew are well developed. The characters speak like young people including cursing and sexual innuendo, and it feels authentic to the characters, not forced or obvious that it's written by an adult. This fictional book evokes real emotions; the grief and angst are almost tangible. The author doles out the tragic plot in a way that was manageable...the reader is allowed time to digest information about a character and given just enough information to wonder what will be revealed next. The dual narration was well done. The narrators sounded age appropriate, that is, they sounded like the teenagers they were narrating without sounding immature or too young. I enjoyed every minute of this book and I am anticipating listening to it again fairly soon.

45 people found this helpful

Uncinematic young love

It's good, not great, but has enough page-turning-ness to rate decently with me. A girl has to re-invent herself after a tragic misfortune. A boy is mysterious and gets on her nerves. Teens are tough in the face of life's unfolding tragedies. Teens.

29 people found this helpful

Decent, but it drags on

This is a well-written book and the story is intriguing. The two main characters have each suffered personal tragedies and terrible losses. As the story progressed, I felt at times like they did not WANT to recover emotionally - as though their misery had become part of their identities. So that made the book a bit dreary after a while.

7 people found this helpful

This is pure perfection!

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

YES! YES! This book is so perfect. The kind that sneaks up on you and hooks you in. It gives you all the feels! This book has the most perfect ending I've read.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Josh, Nastya and Drew were all AMAZING in their own messed up way.

What about Kirby Heyborne and Candace Thaxton ’s performance did you like?

Candace Thaxton did such an AMAZING job! AMAZING! She pull off Nastya perfectly. I'm on stalk mode for more books by her.
Kirby is not my favorite narrator. I don't like his accent and I wish someone else would have done Josh. But, I do have to admit that he pulled off Josh's emotional scenes perfectly which made it all worth it.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

ALL of it! So emotional. But that ending was chill-worthingly perfect!

Any additional comments?

I can’t put off this review any longer. I bought The Sea of Tranquility when it was first released, but it became one of those books that for some reason sat unread on my kindle. Then, after hearing so many great reviews I got the ARC version from Atria. I think it was all of the ‘OMG this is amazing!’ 5 stars reviews that intimidated me. Sometimes I feel like the only one that doesn’t like a book most other people rave about and I don’t like that feeling. I was finally convinced to read this a few months ago and totally got what all the fuss was about. I read this book back in June and was never able to put my feelings about this book into a coherent review. Mostly because nothing I say can do it justice and partly because, really, what else can I possibly say that other bloggers haven’t already. I bought and listened to the audiobook last week and fell in love with it all over again. I decided to just get this review over with already.

I was more than intimidated when I started this book. Especially since my friend is a huge fan and I really think she might have shunned me if I didn’t love the book. Plus, it was long and long books and I don’t really get along. I was immediately intrigued as to what had happened to Nastya to make her the way she was, but I will admit that the beginning was a little bit slow. Not boring, just slow. Then, out of nowhere, and I’m not even sure when or where it happened, I realized I was in love with this book! I fell in love with Josh and Nastya little by little until I was drowning in all the emotions. This book hurt my soul but it was that good kind of hurt.

Even though Nastya was kind of morbid and depression, I couldn’t not like her. Despite of her quirks and self-destructive tendencies, I understood why she was like that. And holy freaking shit, I have so much fangirling about Josh-freaking-Bennett that I don’t even know where to start. I’ll just list my favorites: I loved that he wasn’t the typical bad boy, he wasn’t an asshole, he cooks, he’s really great with his hands (I was referring to the carpentry), but my favorite thing about Josh was his love for General Hospital. Oh yeah, once I found out he was a GH fan I was a goner. Although the story heavily focuses on Josh and Nastya, Drew was such a scene stealer and one of my favorite aspect of the story. I loved his friendship with Josh and his Nastypants and I know I’m not alone when I say that I. WANT. DREW’S. STORY!!!

A little bit on the narration. I thought Candace did such a fantastic job at capturing Nastya’s voice, attitude and feelings. She pulled off every scene brilliantly and I’m looking forward to hearing more audio books by her. I had a harder time getting used to Josh’s voice. Mostly because I thought the narrator sounded a bit too old to pull off Josh. I’ve also heard another book by him and it bothers me how slow he talks. His talking scenes are good but his narrating scenes got on my nerves sometimes. But I will admit this, Kirby did an amazing job at pulling off the really emotional scenes! As if this book wasn’t already emotional, these scenes make it hurt just a little bit more and I kept wishing he had showed more emotion throughout the rest of the book. All in all, I still really enjoyed this audio book and will listen to this again.

Book endings are hard for me. Most of the time I feel like I still need/want more to the story. I can honestly say that this was not the case. This is the most perfect ending I have ever read! Those two words gave me the chills and made me want to go back and read it all over again. This is another one of those books where I am kicking myself for not having read it sooner. All I can say is that it’s one of the most beautiful books I’ve read and I am on full-on stalker to see what story the author has for us next. I can’t say enough good things about it and it will always be one of my ‘auto-recommend’ books.

22 people found this helpful

Barely a storyline,single-dimensional characters

Would you try another book from Katja Millay and/or Kirby Heyborne and Candace Thaxton ?

I would not choose other books by Katya Millay, not based on this particular book.

What was most disappointing about Katja Millay’s story?

The story had only a few points to it which were belaboured in a tourturous narrative of repetitive day to day banalities with characters who took themselves way too seriously. There was little character development. We learned the one or two aspects the author wanted us to know about the characters and then those were hammered home in repeated similar scenes that were not sufficiently interesting.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

The male narrator's pace was quite unnaturally slow.

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

I was disappointed. I kept listening so as to find out the key aspects of the back story that impacted the present so intensely. When they came, they were predictable. The lead character was also built up so much that I was led to expect something remarkable from her, but she was a bystander in her life to the end of the book. I was disappointed.

6 people found this helpful

Wish More Stars Were Available!!

Having read this book on my Kindle TWICE and rated it 5+ stars both times, it was with great trepidation that I downloaded the audible.com version. It even took me almost a MONTH to begin listening to it.Y'all, this book is and was a phenomenal read, so you can imagine the leap of faith to listening to it. Well, let me put you at ease and also congratulate whoever is responsible for bringing the audio version to life. IT'S JUST AS GOOD AND NOTHING IS LOST!! In fact, the audio version adds a dimension to the printed/digital book that simply puts this book (and the author, Katja Millay) into the stratosphere of spectacular writing. There a literally hundreds of 5 star reviews on Amazon, so if you want the eloquence of a great review of the story and Katja's magnificent and powerful writing, go there. I cannot do most of them justice. But listen to me when I say that listening to this book was an experience I will never forget. Initially, I was thinking to myself "Uh-Ho--this isn't working". But knowing that it often takes acclimating to voices you may have heard in your head as you read the book, I stuck with it. And man, was it worth it. There was a tipping point when the narrators BECAME the characters and the book totally came to life. Both Kirby Heyborne and Candace Thaxton were superb in their narration, intonation, voice, timbre and whatever else it took to make this wonderful book a wonderful listen. Sometimes the 'esses' would whistle slightly but not to the point of distractions. The characters of Nastya and Josh were spoken richly by each narrator. I will return to this book again and again when I am beret of a powerful and beautifully crafted story. My three words about this book to all who see this review--LISTEN TO IT!

33 people found this helpful

Beautiful story, but...

I wanted to like this book.
I even started to LOVE this book.
But I found myself in the midst of a little too much teenaged angst and a little too much Kirby Heyborne.
I tried to love it... I really did... but it was an OK read if you're up for teenage angst and sexuality.
Candace Thaxton's performance almost helped carry this book, but Kirby Heyborne (apart from a terrific performance in "Heft") is a narrator I don't listen to much, and now I remember why.

42 people found this helpful