Skating On The Thin Ice Of Life

Shattuck has written a throughly enthralling and captivating novel of vivid Historic Fiction. Set in post WWII Bavaria the story swirls through time and captures Germany before the war. Using character flashbacks and memories, an intense picture of the war is captured. Not since reading the novel Stones From The River by Ursula Hegi have I read a book that succeeds so beautifully in deepening the readers understanding of how WWII Germany could have happened.

The characters are fully and richly developed and this to me makes it possible to understand the impossible. Shattuck was able to make me care about the most unlikely characters. The writing explores the duality of people, what makes us kind or cruel, and how most of life, in the author's opinion, is lived not in black and white, but in shades of grey. This is a difficult story that is horrifying and shockingly sad--but at the same time absolutely riveting.

I don't speak German so I can't comment on the accuracy of the accents and pronunciations of German words in the narration. However, I thought Campbell did an excellent job with the reading. She captured the emotion and feeling behind the words.

If you liked the book The Nightingale I think you will love this book. Be forewarned, this story is grounded in history and leaves you with more questions than clear and easy answers. Thought provoking, subtle and disturbing. I was transfixed.

166 people found this helpful

Surprisingly Good!

This audiobook kept me up late... Needed to hear the next chapter, and was glued to the story. The author gave us a very different look at the war and how it changed its people. Despite much of the story being sad, it was also a story of hope and the power of time's ability to ease the burden of painful memories. Cassandra Campbell certainly outdid herself, with incredible performances for each of the characters. At no point did I have any trouble figuring out which of the persons was speaking. Also, her accents were spot-on. Interestingly, for the most part, I am not usually a fan of hers, mostly because she tends to over dramatize everything... But not this time. 👍🏼😊 Will recommend the audiobook to others.

101 people found this helpful

A Different View of WWII

There have been SO many WWII books recently that, frankly, the subject has been overused. This is a different look at the impact of the horrors of Hitler's regime, from the perspective of three German women who support and survive together in the final months of the conflict. Each of these characters represents a different point of view. Marianne is the social conscious of those Germans who opposed Hitler; Benita represents those who were indifferent until they are personally affected,and Ania is, like many, a supported and follower of the Nazi party until its power becomes excessive. An emotional story, well read by Cassandra Campbell ( one of the best narrators ever). This would have rated (5) stars but the final section of the story, set in 1992, felt unnessecary, and diminished the emotional impact of the main story (1945-1950).

17 people found this helpful

well written

very interesting Story a different view for sure , Narrator did a great job ,I liked it a lot
the only critic I have is that they called Germany the Motherland it is not it's the Fatherland
that kind of irritated me a little but the book itself is good

12 people found this helpful

Another WW2 women's novel, but with nuance

The novel begins in a decrepit German castle immediately after the end of World War II. Marianne von Lingenfels, widow of one of the members of the failed July plot against Hitler, feels a moral obligation to find and help other widows and children of resistors who worked with her husband and were murdered by the Nazis.

First of all, Marianne wants to find Benita and Martin, the young wife and son of Constantine Fledermann, the dashing man she grew up with and always secretly loved. Then Marianne learns that Ania, the widow of a man she met only once, is in a displaced-persons camp nearby, with her two sons.

The three women come together to live in the castle, with their children. They are such different people, and their reactions to postwar realities differ as well. In later parts, the novel looks back at each woman’s story before and during the war. Each has secrets in her past that she doesn’t share with the others.

After several decades of reading WW2 fiction and non-fiction, I’ve become leery of novels involving the Nazi era. Too often the stories are sensationalistic and paint everyone as good or bad. They rely on our knowledge of what happened under the Nazis to color our views of their characters, without adequately taking into account that those characters didn’t know then what we know now. Jessica Shattuck manages to avoid those weaknesses.

A brief (I hope) digression: Not long ago, I went to a book club meeting to discuss The Zookeeper’s Wife, about a young woman in Warsaw who, together with her husband and children, hid Jews and others sought by the Nazis. Our talk led to a discussion of what we would have done if we lived in Germany or its conquered countries during the Nazi era. Only one member was certain she would have dared to resist the Nazis and help their victims, and I think she was kidding herself. Nobody can know that for certain, and history suggests that most people, even if sympathetic, will not risk much to help.

The reason why I bring up that book club story is because the real strength of this book, is Jessica Shattuck’s depiction of ordinary German citizens in this novel. The resistors are very much in the minority and not a significant part of the story. It’s everybody else we are shown, in all their self-absorbed and petty concerns.

Living through such a momentous time in history didn’t make them bigger people. If they were sharp-tongued, judgmental, or selfish before the war, or even if they just avoided inconvenient truths and focused only on their personal concerns, they stayed that way, through the war and afterward. This self-absorption allowed them to resent having their American occupiers shove their noses in the truth about the Nazi death camps, rather than to come to moral terms with their country’s wrongdoing. They didn’t feel responsible for what happened to the Jews and the Nazis’ other victims; they said they didn’t know, they couldn’t have done anything. Anyway, that was all in the past and why can’t people get on with their lives?

Shattuck doesn’t depict these people as bad people. She makes the reader see that they are ordinary, just like the people all around us today. They are not admirable, but they are all too real. And when you look at all the things happening in the world today, it becomes easier to see the small steps and self-justifications that can result in people effectively, if not intentionally, becoming complicit in terrible acts. Bravo to Jessica Shattuck for conveying that reality so subtly and effectively.

I would give the narrator of the audiobook, Cassandra Campbell, somewhere around a C+ or B- grade. She was just fine most of the time, but I felt like she didn’t adequately differentiate between various women’s voices and she occasionally mispronounced German words.

63 people found this helpful

A Thought-provoking Work of Historical Fiction

There's something about learning history through the eyes of fictional characters that engages our senses and crystallizes the impact world affairs have had in humanity in ways no history class ever could.

Perhaps nowhere is this more evident than in our obsession with WWII novels. The scale of that tragedy is so unfathomable that there's always hope that one more story could help us make sense of it all. In The Women In The Castle author Jessica Shattuck offers a nuanced perspective of Post-war Germany told through the lives of three unique female characters.

The story begins on November 9th, 1938 in Burg Lingenfels, a beautiful isolated Bavarian castle. Marianne von Lingenfels is hosting the annual harvest party thrown by her husband's Albrecht aunt, an elderly countess known for her rebellious spirit and anti-German views.

Albrecht Lingenfels and Connie Fledermann, Marianne’s childhood friend, are part of a group of German men involved in a plot to assassinate Hitler. As they conspire, they make Marianne promise that if the plot fails, she must do everything she can to help the wives left behind, including Benita, Connie's soon to be young wife.

The Women in the Castle is at its core a complex moral story but is also a tale of resilience and survival. It narrates how three widows, from very different backgrounds, become the most unlikely of friends trying to navigate the tumultuous, confusing aftermath of WWII.

Thus, mostly forced by their extraordinary circumstances, an unlikely alliance is forged and the castle becomes a temporary refuge for these women and their children, as they painfully and slowly attempt to put their lives back together.

I think the author gets many things right, especially that sense that for many ordinary Germans, the rise of Hitler and Nazism had a slow-boiling kind of feeling and so, by the time many people realize what was happening it was already too late. This is not to absolve those that were directly or indirectly involved, but this novel certainly provides a more nuanced perspective on how the Germans allowed for the Holocaust to occur.

Cassandra Campbel is a seasoned, talented narrator and she proves it once again on this remarkable performance.

Recommended for anyone looking for an engaging, thought-provoking work of historical fiction.

56 people found this helpful

Just okay

This book had promise but fell flat for me. I had just read The Nightingale, which I had given 5 stars and then I read this one and was disappointed. The plot was jumpy and didn't flow well for me. Some characters and plot pieces felt missing or could have been developed better. I appreciate learning about aspects of World War II, so that part was interesting but overall it didn't work for me.

20 people found this helpful

This should have been a great book

I was really looking forward to this book. It could have been great, but I feel the author and her Editor really dropped the ball. It was very confusing due to jumps between decades and going back again. Trying to surprise the reader with who these women really were just made for awkward listening. I truly only finished it as I figured since I bought it, I might as well finish it. I do not recommend this book.

25 people found this helpful

Talk like a woman, please

Any additional comments?

Such strong female characters, such breathy portrayals. Cassandra Campbell performs every single woman in this book by going way up high and adding lots of air -- even the main character, who as written is forceful, driven and uncompromising. Drove me crazy.

61 people found this helpful

Weaker than other contemporary stories

I've spent the past year enjoying a dozen or so historical fiction, WWII, resistance-themed books. This was the weakest of them. I never became engaged with the characters nor inspired by their actions. Cassandra Campbell does not rank among my favorite narrators, and her portrayals here were disappointing. Her German accent made every single sentence sound like a question.

32 people found this helpful