Two thumbs way up.

Love this series and Elizabeth Hoyt never disappoints not like some authors. I truly enjoyed the pairing of the monkish Winter and the experienced widow Isabelle. The Maiden Lane series is just so great. This book has it all a great story, hot romance, an excellent cast of characters, humor drama and mystery. Ashford McNabb is beyond awesome. Her timing, male and female voices, accents and talent land her in the creme de la creme of narrators. Highly recommend this book, narrator and author.

10 people found this helpful

I loved the story!!!

I loved this story, it truly gave me a glimpse of the man behind the mask....Winter is my second favorite character and I am thrilled for the sneak peek into book number 5....

6 people found this helpful

EXCELLENT

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

OH Yes, it was a great story,it works as a stand alone, however you would get an in depth view if you have read the 1st 3 books.

This is Winter Makepeace's story, he was an amazing character, with a fascinating past, which is revealed with perfect pacing between action and passion.

What did you like best about this story?

I love Winter and Isabelle's characters, they were perfect together. I actually LOVED her maid, she was a little nutty & obsessed with Isabelle's clothing.( she's really cute)

What does Ashford MacNab bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

She is one of my favourite narrarators, I could not imagine anyone else reading this series.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

Introduce yourself to the Man behind the Mask.

Any additional comments?

Worth the credit! Enjoy!!!

4 people found this helpful

YOU JUST CAN'T GO WRONG WITH AN E.H LISTEN

The positive reviewers before me have pretty much summed this book up so all I can add are words, words like:-

Humorous, thrilling, exciting, sexy, passionate, addictive listening, likeable characters, interesting plot with desire, mayhem and danger.

Desperately looking forward to book 5 Lord of Darkness which I've already pre-ordered..... and long may they continue.

Worth a credit? If you're a historical/romance lover then it's just got to be a Yes to this one and you won't be disappointed if you spend your credits on the whole series.

8 people found this helpful

Elizabeth Hoyt?

I remember reading EH's books as a woman in my 20's. They all hinted at desire and passion, but were cloaked in innuendoes. Not this series. I was so excited to see this last installment of the series! The first 4 books had all the intrigue and passion I love in a good historical romance novel. This book had an interesting twist, in that it is the man who is the "innocent". The characters are very interesting, and the mystery surrounding the missing children is slowly built in a manner that had me sitting on the edge of my seat with anticipation of what would happen next. Reading the first books in the series is not a must, but does give a lot of insight into the male protaganist's persona. And the chapter beginnings telling tales of "The Ghost of St. Giles" is a stroke of real genius. If you like historical romances with lots of mystery, intrigue and hot, hot, hot desire, I cannot recommend this series enough.

Also, Ms. McNab, while not quite in Ann Floxniks league, does a very good portrayal of the different voices of the characters.

3 people found this helpful

LOVE LOVE that series

No words would give this series and this book justice! LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT!
Just trust me and buy it :)

2 people found this helpful

Another Great Addition to the Series!

Thief of Shadows by Elizabeth Hoyt (Audio Edition)
Narrated by Ashford McNab
Maiden Lane series #4

♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ This book was great! I loved Winter Makepeace. He is such an honourable man and he keeps himself this way until Lady Beckinhall threatens his sanity. These two together are fantastic! I loved how the roles were reversed, she the more experience and he the innocent. She the aggressor and teacher, though Winter stole that role some times.

There was some great action.. How could there not be when the Ghost of St.Giles is around. The lead characters had some wonderful moments, great banter and awesome chemistry. Who knew I would have to say yet again: that this is my favourite of the series so far!!

This may sound foolish, and I know they are just children… but I really want Joseph Tinbox and Peach to get a story later in this series. He could be all grown up and comeback to her after years of letters.. Yes.. I know, I am ever the romantic!!

I have already downloaded book 5 in this series and can’t wait to read it! I am sad to see that the narrator is not the same... as Ashford McNab is fantastic! Here's hoping this new narrator can compare!

1 person found this helpful

MY, MY, MY!!!! STEAMING HOT!

Would you listen to Thief of Shadows again? Why?

Absolutely! I couldn't hardly weight for Winter's story and I wasn't disappointed. Elizabeth Hoyt delivers!!! Winter and Isabel have a great story and there's plenty of lust, sex and finally love. Hot, hot, hot!

Who was your favorite character and why?

Winter because he struggles to define himself as both a man with carnal desires and the Ghost of St. Giles. He is so honest and cares so deeply and honestly that you have to fall in love with him.

Have you listened to any of Ashford MacNab’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Yes and I think she does a good job. At times I think she reads in a monotone, but I'm so used to her as the characters for the Maiden Lane Series that it doesn't bother me. I would definitely listen to other books narrated by Ms. MacNab.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Absolutely. This book keeps you engaged and holds your attention even through the last word spoken.

Any additional comments?

What a cliff hanger! My only regret is that I started this series before the whole series was complete. Now I have to wait several months between each release. This book ends on the best cliff hanger with a startling revelation of the Ghost of St. Giles, so I can't hardly wait for the next book.

1 person found this helpful

Loved It!

What did you love best about Thief of Shadows?

I loved everything, the story is fantastic and keeps you reading - I couldn't stop, pretty much read it through in one sitting. I love this series, it has been really fun, and I can't wait for the next book to come out. The ending was a bit of a surprise, I thought this would be the end of the series when it was revealed that Winter is the Ghost - but the end is nice and gives a twist that wasn't expected.

Any additional comments?

Can't wait for the next book to see where the Ghost takes us next!

2 people found this helpful

Loved it

Thief of Shadows ( Maiden Lane Book 4 ) by Elizabeth Hoyt Amazing! 5 + stars. I absolutely found a true love in this author. This one love match with a twist. Winter Makepeace is a dream. A school master in the day time and The Ghost of St. Giles at night. A strong head widow Isabel Beckinhall who cared nothing for the gossip and did everything in her power to find out the Identity of The Ghost of St. Giles and make him see the other side of a good live full of love. The humor, LOVED IT . I'm in love with Winter This book was a page turner for me. The love scene amazing that never disappoints. I'm on Book 5 and already loving Godric <3